Sub Vocalists who have improved since their debut days?

Tzuyu improved a lot

Quote from lialve

So Wendy did improve.

She def sounds better to me than at debut

Never said she didn't improve, I said their improvements aren't as big as the others I mentioned. Also, the thread is about Sub-Vocalists, not Main or Lead-Vocalists.

Sub Vocalist are the members with the weaker vocals so usually are the Dancers, Rappers or some cases the Visual.

Using TWICE as an example they would be Tzuyu and Momo as Jeongyeon and Mina are Sub-Leads, Dahyun and Chaeyoung are Rappers/Vocals, Sana is a Dancer/Vocal, JiHyo and Nayeon are the Main and Lead.

Tzuyu and Momo have definitely improved over the years, mainly due to TWICE's Songs not being in a high key in their later years.

Quote from David33

I worked with singers, my mother is a vocal coach too, I know everything about this. They didn't improve much since their debut, I follow their career since day 1, they're one of my favorite Kpop singers. Like I said, they were amazing since the beginning. Just because their technique seems more effortless and better, doesn't mean they improved a LOT! Never said they didn't improve. Compared to those I listed already, it's not a big improvement.

I won't argue about this, because I don't see the point. If you want to learn something about vocals and techniques, you can read it here:

Taeyeon: Girls’ Generation’s Vocal Analysis: Taeyeon [Newly Updated] | K-pop Vocalists' Vocal Analyses

Wendy: Red Velvet’s Vocal Analysis: Wendy | K-pop Vocalists' Vocal Analyses

Display More

I see a good difference in how they sound now compared to how they sounded at debut.

Quote from David33

I think Taeyeon and Wendy are probably the only SM vocalists who didn't really evolved.

Taeyeon's INVU is her best vocals performance ever. It doesn't make sense what you are trying to say.

I won't argue, I grew up listening to Celin Dion and the likes so I know what I'm talking about.

Quote from jimeous

Sub Vocalist are the members with the weaker vocals so usually are the Dancers, Rappers or some cases the Visual.

Using TWICE as an example they would be Tzuyu and Momo as Jeongyeon and Mina are Sub-Leads, Dahyun and Chaeyoung are Rappers/Vocals, Sana is a Dancer/Vocal, JiHyo and Nayeon are the Main and Lead.

Tzuyu and Momo have definitely improved over the years, mainly due to TWICE's Songs not being in a high key in their later years.

We're doing "sub-leads" now? What's next, major leads & minor leads? And why did you categorize Sana as a dancer/vocal? They all dance. Mina & Tzuyu are the lead dancers, not that it makes much of a difference.