Serious question about album sales post 2nd gen

  • How is it that today and even in 3rd gen groups sell more and more with each comeback when during 2nd gen groups would peak and then start selling less and less with each comeback?


    TVXQ and Super Junior were the two best selling groups of 2nd gen but they did eventually peak by year 5 and began to sell less each time. Usually a couple hundred thousand less.


    Then you look at a group like Seventeen who apparently is selling more with each comeback. Millions more actually.


    Yes kpop is bigger today and is worldwide but that still doesn't add up to me. Let's say for example Seventeen somehow managed to get 1 million new fans since their last release. That doesn't automatically mean 1 million new sales. Buying albums is still a niche practice these days. Most people are just gonna listen Seventeen on spotify or YouTube. Only die hard fans buy albums and sometimes not even them.


    My boy Eman is a huge ONCE but I don't think he has ever bought a Twice album. Or any kpop album. And this isn't shade it's just reality.


    So where are these sales coming from for a veteran group like Seventeen or any group who manages to double or their sales with every release?


    If Super Junior were increasing their sales like todays groups they would be at 20 million pre orders by now.


    Something is not adding up right.

  • Just increase the gimmicks in every comeback and that should do the trick.


    In the end, every group has a cap on how many fans they can get, then taking into consideration their older fans starting to spend less on CDs and merch, the gimmicks are just a must after a while.


    Another problem is being publicly traded, you need to show results.

    Edited once, last by Person01 ().

  • Globalization. In my country, I didn’t even dream or think of buying SNSD physical albums because shipping wasn’t this easy and only adults (who probably for work/home related purposes) can do it. You gotta realize it was a time where Online shopping wasn’t a popular thing yet.


    Life has changed a lot since then. Now 7 year olds can buy many albums (they’re also cheaper and have a lot of discounts) easily from anywhere in the world. Every K-pop fan now can compete for their favs’ sales when it was restricted to certain countries. Not to mention things like online fansign where anyone in the world could “meet” their fav if they buy many albums.

                                                   


        lt64IYu.gif


Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!