was ive always good at singing?

they're pretty solid and sound exactly the official song but i rmbr they got trashed for their previous encore stages. did they improve or were they always good?

They've improved for a lot. The encores they got bashed for recently had mic issues or even mics completely being turned off. This Show Champion one was pretty good. I don't know why anyone would bash this encore, it's better than most groups and the song has some decently high parts. Wonyoung has the most noticeable improvement, honestly surprised she can sing her parts acceptably with decent volume.

They don't sing live that often during performances but at MCD they did and it's also good in my opinion:

[MR Removed] IVE - AFTER LIKE (M!Countdown) MR제거 20220901 (Live Vocals)

* Clean MR Removed* Live Vocals* No copyright Infringement Intended

www.youtube.com

I guess people just want to find reasons to hate on them since they're doing so well. It's not like they're claiming to be a strong vocal group. More lines for Liz though, she should have the most lines in every song.

this is good to you? remember when kpop had real vocalists.....

They were doing good since first encore though. The only one that got hate was Wonyoung because she didn't sing but then she did in all the next ones.

That’s good? The bar is so low now in kpop.

Quote from Wholesome Anons Poster (37)

this is good to you? remember when kpop had real vocalists.....

Quote from Positive Anons Poster (261)

That’s good? The bar is so low now in kpop.

i said "theyre solid and sound exactly like the official song" tell me which part of that is false? and you guys always come in talking about real vocalists but my ears literally bleed listening to "strong vocal groups" like aespa and nmixx. ive songs are good and they sound the exact same live so of course i'm going to think theyre good.

Lol 3rd and 2nd gen stans that are butthurt in this post because some rookie beat their favs

They sound pitchy

they're good, yes.

Why they do that someone singing then interrupt with their voice I think they’re hiding they can’t hit those notes

a few debut encores were a bit unstable but it was likely the nerves, i think they are fine, they aren't some top vocals but they are young and improving, do their songs fine live and has nice vocal tones, i don't even ask for more for pop groups.

Wonyoung improved a lot since her izone days, is clearly she didn't even trained until she returned to starship and it shows

they are all bad singers lol

this counts for good? their songs are easy as hell and they still sound pitchy, not a single real vocalist in sight except for Liz

the rest can basically just hold a tune, the bar is so low it's in hell. Put them on stage next to someone who can ACTUALLY sing and it'll just be embarrassing

that's good? even enhypen sounds better than them at this point lol