Min Heejin shouldn't be allowed to work with minors.

this NEEDS to be talked about more.

Once again, she has known Krystal since she was a child:

Yup. Definitely a weirdo.

I think you are reaching

Half of these tweets are either deleted or from private accounts, flop

it's weird that nobody have said anything about min heejin before but only after she came up with the bomb that is new jeans, it looks like people are threatened and trying to bring her down. praying for the new jeans kids who will be dragged along with min heejin.

She reminds me of the woman who headed up Wildfox and Selkie. Not much originality, but the ability to pull good cohesive aesthetics from movies and old music videos. I don't think anything about the NJ mv's is inappropriate so far.

Quote from Stewed Almonds & Avocado Ostrich (385)

Half of these tweets are either deleted or from private accounts, flop

They weren't private when I posted the thread.

I can summarize it though:

• She has a track record of sexualising idols that she has known since they were young teens as soon as they hit legal age.
• She called 14 year old Krystal her muse
• Taemin was also her favourite Shinee member even when he was underage
• The Sherlock photoshoot with Shinee. Do I have to elaborate...
• Furthermore, she kept it a secret from Taemin that he'll have to go shirtless for the photoshoot so that he doesn't work out in advance and looks "boyish". In a sexualised photoshoot. And another member's abs were photoshopped out so that he would look younger!!
• Another tweet was an Exo-L noting that this information made them see debut Exo content in a different light. An user in the reply confirmed that then-underage Kai was her favourite. Do you see the pattern now?
• She took Hyein (the 14 year old) New Jeans member to places, including her house, said she found a friend in her, and talked in a creepy way about "bathing in her refreshing energy" and how the weather made it even better...???

she has poster of nude girls in her walls

Post it in the main, I dare you op.

Why only do this now? Why not expose her a long time ago?

Quote from Smoked Mustard & Rosemary Rabbit (981)

Post it in the main, I dare you op.

I posted it in anons exactly because of people like you who cannot accept criticism of anyone affiliated with HYBE/SM (whichever you stan) and immediately fabricate narratives about the intentions of anyone who does it anyway.

Quote from Smoked Mustard & Rosemary Rabbit (981)

Why only do this now? Why not expose her a long time ago?

People are saying the Sherlock photoshoot was controversial even back then. It's unfortunate people are only learning about this now but it's likely because most of these things happened a long time ago, were known mostly only by the fans of the groups she worked with, and Min Heejin wasn't nearly as relevant before Ador.

Quote from Smoked Mustard & Rosemary Rabbit (981)

Post it in the main, I dare you op.

Why only do this now? Why not expose her a long time ago?

Same as bullying scandals. Before she was an regular employee and now she is top mgmt of Ador who debut her own group. Who are 13/14. The age she prefers.

Same happens with presidential candidates. You save the dirt until you can use it. Doesn’t make it fake.

y'all are so desperate 🤣

Quote from Deep-Fried Sour Ostrich (575)

y'all are so desperate 🤣

I’m not a sm stan so I don’t know much but we can’t deny her behavior seems weird

She definitely done many questionable stuffs and need to apologize soon or later

But i also know karma will come back to get all the bitter sm stans only involving in this mess just bcz they can stand an ex sm employee having more success after leaving their favorite company

You guys just wait

Quote from OP

I posted it in anons exactly because of people like you who cannot accept criticism of anyone affiliated with HYBE/SM (whichever you stan) and immediately fabricate narratives about the intentions of anyone who does it anyway.

People are saying the Sherlock photoshoot was controversial even back then. It's unfortunate people are only learning about this now but it's likely because most of these things happened a long time ago, were known mostly only by the fans of the groups she worked with, and Min Heejin wasn't nearly as relevant before Ador.

huh? Discuss in the main. Don't be a coward. Main had diverse participants.

Quote from Simmered Pepper & Garlic Rabbit (268)

Same as bullying scandals. Before she was an regular employee and now she is top mgmt of Ador who debut her own group. Who are 13/14. The age she prefers.

Same happens with presidential candidates. You save the dirt until you can use it. Doesn’t make it fake.

so you're saying she's paedo?

Quote from Smoked Mustard & Rosemary Rabbit (981)

so you're saying she's paedo?

She sure caters to the segment. Maybe not for her but SK is a creepy place with regards to exploitation if minors.

With some of the evidence in this thread it’s worrying.

Quote from Breaded Rhubarb Turkey (935)

She definitely done many questionable stuffs and need to apologize soon or later

"sorry I didn't know sexualising minors was bad, I'll reflect hard, bye"

Quote from Breaded Rhubarb Turkey (935)

But i also know karma will come back to get all the bitter sm stans only involving in this mess just bcz they can stand an ex sm employee having more success after leaving their favorite company

You guys just wait

Is this really all you're getting from this???? Fans of SM groups, especially shawols, brought these things up because they dislike her for the things she has done to young idols.

Your ridiculous assumptions about their intentions only says something about you.

Quote from Smoked Mustard & Rosemary Rabbit (981)

huh? Discuss in the main. Don't be a coward. Main had diverse participants.

"coward"

You're seriously talking like this is some kind of fanwar or at least attack against your fave. I've explained already. I don't want to personally deal with losers who think this is an attack against their fave company.

Quote from Deep-Fried Sour Ostrich (575)

y'all are so desperate 🤣

Grow up. This is a serious topic, for the sake of the New Jeans members. Do you care more about the idols or the reputation of their company?

Quote from Dried Orange & Olive Lamb (452)

it's weird that nobody have said anything about min heejin before but only after she came up with the bomb that is new jeans, it looks like people are threatened and trying to bring her down. praying for the new jeans kids who will be dragged along with min heejin.

It's disgusting that you're treating this as an attack against NJ. People are talking about this for THEIR sake.

And actually, people did talk about her weird actions way before she created NJ, or even left SM. It's just becoming relevant again.

Quote from OP

They weren't private when I posted the thread.

I can summarize it though:

• She has a track record of sexualising idols that she has known since they were young teens as soon as they hit legal age.
• She called 14 year old Krystal her muse
• Taemin was also her favourite Shinee member even when he was underage
• The Sherlock photoshoot with Shinee. Do I have to elaborate...
• Furthermore, she kept it a secret from Taemin that he'll have to go shirtless for the photoshoot so that he doesn't work out in advance and looks "boyish". In a sexualised photoshoot. And another member's abs were photoshopped out so that he would look younger!!
• Another tweet was an Exo-L noting that this information made them see debut Exo content in a different light. An user in the reply confirmed that then-underage Kai was her favourite. Do you see the pattern now?
• She took Hyein (the 14 year old) New Jeans member to places, including her house, said she found a friend in her, and talked in a creepy way about "bathing in her refreshing energy" and how the weather made it even better...???

The not informing taemin thing is creepy but just having minor members as ur favorite members doesn't mean she's a creep like how many people stan ive and newjeans and have underage members as their favorites doesn't mean they are creeps.

wait I thought sm stans on main were saying that all the concepts min heejin did at SM were done by a team so she can't get full credit for accomplishments like exo pathcode or fx pink tape?

so basically you are saying SM is extremely problematic for supporting and promoting these allegedly pedo concepts? I agree!

Quote from Pressure-Cooked Salted Pigeon (59)

The not informing taemin thing is creepy but just having minor members as ur favorite members doesn't mean she's a creep like how many people stan ive and newjeans and have underage members as their favorites doesn't mean they are creeps.

And the styling? Thats pretty creepy.

kpop has always been predatory, fans just turned a blind eyes to it

-debut super young

-wear revealing clothes, 'concept' is just an excuse

-military performance for hundred of men

-this goes for bg too

in marketing, sex sells.

But I thought she didn't even did that much in SM, that's what they preach in main.

Choose a narrative, she was in charge of their concepts or not, not the two things just because you want to bring a group down.

Quote from Simmered Pepper & Garlic Rabbit (238)

wait I thought sm stans on main were saying that all the concepts min heejin did at SM were done by a team so she can't get full credit for accomplishments like exo pathcode or fx pink tape?

I wasn't talking about concepts but specific shoots and styling choices credited to her, and things she said herself.

Quote from Simmered Pepper & Garlic Rabbit (238)

so basically you are saying SM is extremely problematic for supporting and promoting these allegedly pedo concepts? I agree!

Both SM and your beloved Hybe are problematic, yes.

Quote from Pressure-Cooked Salted Pigeon (59)

but just having minor members as ur favorite members doesn't mean she's a creep like how many people stan ive and newjeans and have underage members as their favorites doesn't mean they are creeps.

Fans and MHJ are not in the same position, and fans also don't have a history of making idols partake in sexualised concepts as soon as they hit legal age, or even before that.

Why don't you write to Hybe instead of complaining here?

Be more proactive

Quote from Marinated Egg & Beans Boar (299)

Choose a narrative, she was in charge of their concepts or not, not the two things just because you want to bring a group down.

jfc I brought up specific photoshoots credited to her and interviews. I don't stan a single SM group so idk why you act like I care about your stupid hybe vs sm stan drama.

I don't want to bring NJ down, the people whose tweets I embedded don't want to bring NJ down either. People are genuinely worried, you know. Like they are when they see any other 14 year old debuting. And now, in addition to some of the members being really young, MHJ has a history that cannot and shouldn't be ignored.

I don’t think it’s weird if you favorite member in a group is the youngest or a minor. They were all too young for her anyways. The other things are def weird

Yikes. I did noticed that Hyein seemed to have the most odd shots in the MVs but I thought nothing of it because its not really in your face and it just seemed that Hyein likes to perform like that and people in production thought it was cute. But I'm rethinking now how much that was actually Min Heejin's influence.

Quote from Simmered Pepper & Garlic Rabbit (238)

wait I thought sm stans on main were saying that all the concepts min heejin did at SM were done by a team so she can't get full credit for accomplishments like exo pathcode or fx pink tape?

so basically you are saying SM is extremely problematic for supporting and promoting these allegedly pedo concepts? I agree!

It is done by a team, a team in which she was involved in ALL cases it happened which is what makes her work with minors odd. Don't play dumb.

You do realize Min Heejin and Krystal are still incredibly close to this day and Soojung supports NewJeans right? If Krystal wanted to do a bath photoshoot as an adult, that's her business and it's fine

I can't speak for what happens with the bgs but this is reaching. And tbh, SM was making very questionable content with minor groups back then with or without Heejin.

Quote from OP

They weren't private when I posted the thread.

I can summarize it though:

• She has a track record of sexualising idols that she has known since they were young teens as soon as they hit legal age.
• She called 14 year old Krystal her muse
• Taemin was also her favourite Shinee member even when he was underage
• The Sherlock photoshoot with Shinee. Do I have to elaborate...
• Furthermore, she kept it a secret from Taemin that he'll have to go shirtless for the photoshoot so that he doesn't work out in advance and looks "boyish". In a sexualised photoshoot. And another member's abs were photoshopped out so that he would look younger!!
• Another tweet was an Exo-L noting that this information made them see debut Exo content in a different light. An user in the reply confirmed that then-underage Kai was her favourite. Do you see the pattern now?
• She took Hyein (the 14 year old) New Jeans member to places, including her house, said she found a friend in her, and talked in a creepy way about "bathing in her refreshing energy" and how the weather made it even better...???

This looks like a witch hunt tbh

1. Every company pushes to sexualize idols as soon as they turn legal. That's a company decision to change their image, not Min Heejin.

2. A muse is someone who inspired your art. That's it. There's nothing sexual about it and some of the idols mentioned here were the visuals/center of their group.

3. There's literally nothing wrong with going places with Hyein and developing a bond with her. That's being a good boss that makes your artists feel comfortable. You have to be really reaching to take that comment about her energy in a sexual way.

SM stans have to be the biggest crybullies on the site but accusing someone of pedophilia is a new low

OP must think Krystal is shady too because she is still following MHJ and liked a NJ post on insta

all this time she was at sm nobody complain about this but now that she has left sm and is in the other team and is doing her own thing SM stan want to bring her antics.

Honestly the only problematic thing in your comment is the shinee photoshoot, for the rest, if we follow your logic, half of the kpop community shouldn't be around minor lol.

For Krystal she was already an adult so it between her and min heejin and SM, now from what have seen min heejin and Krystal are still very close.

Quote from Brined Mustard & Thyme Horse (383)

This looks like a witch hunt tbh

1. Every company pushes to sexualize idols as soon as they turn legal. That's a company decision to change their image, not Min Heejin.

2. A muse is someone who inspired your art. That's it. There's nothing sexual about it and some of the idols mentioned here were the visuals/center of their group.

3. There's literally nothing wrong with going places with Hyein and developing a bond with her. That's being a good boss that makes your artists feel comfortable. You have to be really reaching to take that comment about her energy in a sexual way.

SM stans have to be the biggest crybullies on the site but accusing someone of pedophilia is a new low

Display More

You’re not legal at 14.

Also you would be in here crying if a man had done the same.

Quote from OP

I wasn't talking about concepts but specific shoots and styling choices credited to her, and things she said herself.

Both SM and your beloved Hybe are problematic, yes.

I don't have a single fav in Hybe lol so I have no problems admitting Hybe is crap. however i'm glad you are admitting SM has been a pedo factory for years - please post this on main, I'd like to see what people, especially the SM stans there have to say

Quote from Dried Orange & Olive Lamb (452)

OP must think Krystal is shady too because she is still following MHJ and liked a NJ post on insta

No, I don't. This isn't about how Krystal sees MHJ, but about what way MHJ presents minors to the audience. Two very different topics.