did stayc flopped with Beautiful Monster?

  • Their song not even on top 100 after 6 hours? I thought people in korea like them?

    I obviously didn't expect top 10 or something, but not even top 90?


    discuss.

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.
  • Lol it did enter top 100 melon in it first hour. For 24hit melon. Let see how it doing tomorrow. Duh

  • They were never one of the 4th gen top ggs that their fans think they are. ASAP is their only hit and is stuck in the 480m points, RUN2U did a AF and Queendom performance in SK and probably will end up with lesser digital points. Stereotype and So Bad straight up flopped. Their songs needs promoting to have a decent performance on charts, that is why ASAP and R2U hitted their peak, BM could do well, but they aren't in the big tier of gg that do good in the first hours

  • I like the song but I think it'd have some well with a soloist.

  • Wait until a week to determine what flopped or not.

  • I'm actually surprised. Stayc is pretty decent size mid group and the song was really good...

  • I'm actually surprised. Stayc is pretty decent size mid group and the song was really good...

    the song is fine but it lacks the usual catchy stayc flavor to make it special and memorable. it’s a bit too staid and placid and the mv also doesn’t help. I’m not surprised at all that it’s not doing as well as their other songs

  • the song is fine but it lacks the usual catchy stayc flavor to make it special and memorable. it’s a bit too staid and placid and the mv also doesn’t help. I’m not surprised at all that it’s not doing as well as their other songs

    Agree, it lacks the usual Stayc flavor. And there's no hook imo.

    Tho I appreciate for being different than usual.

  • The song isn't memorable and StayC's vocals are going the Itzy's way that ruins the song more

  • they had a comeback?

  • Can't be sure. They are slow risers. I don't think they ever hit high first day.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!