Revising Aespa's positions based on how their comebacks have been going

    Winter - Main vocal, lead dancer, sub-rapper, visual

    Karina - Main dancer, main rapper, lead vocal, leader, visual, center

    Ningning - Lead vocal

    Giselle - Lead rapper


    Giselle and Karina probably get the same number of raps but Karina's sound more like raps/better while they make Giselle go super high like in Savage or whatever she was doing for her first rap part in Girls. As for Winter/Ningning, their producers have clearly been showing a preference for Winter lately - she had more lines than Ningning in Girls and got the high note in both Girls and DT

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    I saw a similar comment in YouTube.

    Concerning Winter and Ningning, they had like 7 seconds of difference in the mini album ;-)

    Winter has only 3 seconds more than Ningning in Girls. People are so dramatic.


    Maybe since Winter’s line in BM was the only viral~ish part, they started giving her more seconds to go viral. It happened again on NL so they just sticked with it. Imho her tone is unique and she sings different genres exceptionally in different styles but the extra high notes they give her are a big NO. It’s unfair to her voice and to Ningning who can do them better.

    Anybody with clean ears can hear that NingNing is a better vocalist than Winter. The "with my frieends" run in Girls proves it alone. Winter's voice when doing high notes sounds very unpleasant. Also, NingNing's high notes in Savage were better than Winter's.

    NingNing is the main vocal because if we go by this logic Winter should also be the main dancer based on what some think.

    If only it was possible for kpop groups that have multiple main vocalists at the same time, this would be a non issue.

    why isn´t this on main kpop threads?

    Karina is the ace of the group. She's the best at dancing, rapping and vocals and has the best visuals.

    I just know they need to stop making Winter do the high notes, girly is so shrill when she does them

    give them to NingNing or better yet stop forcing these wailing high notes in every song

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login