-
-
Moderator
Approved the thread. -
First of all Jennie didn't have an album release, it was a digital single and photobook release. Plus its 2022, you are being dumb to say that.
2nd idk about Lisa's sales but maybe Rosé, she has 4 standard versions and other type of versions plus its a mini and it will count towards bb200 and jyp gave her Target release that counts towards bb so I am expecting US onces to purchase a lot. She should definitely do 500k first month easily.
-
Way lower
-
all sales are inflated post covid
-
-
-
probably over 1m and maybe close to 2m if the songs are good
-
-
-
not a once, but i don't think that's a fair comparison
bp has been promoted as soloist for a while now (individual instas/yts and tiktok for years, individual brand endorsments, individual variety attendances,..) while twice was always promoted as OT9 (?)
Nayeon might be one of the most popular twice members, she hasn't established her fan base enough yet to compare her with lisa or rose.
that being said, it would be insane if she does similar numbers.
-
-
She has worldwide/US distribution (+Target exclusive) unlike Chaelisa so she might be not be far from them, I think her hanteo number will be lower since her mini will be available on many stores and is also on Twice official store so fans don't have to use Ktown4u and other online stores that count for hanteo.
-
all sales are inflated post covid
True. That makes things hard to predict or forecast.
Nayeon isn't outselling twice
That would indeed be unexpected.
Somehow I don't think this makes that much of a difference.
Display Morenot a once, but i don't think that's a fair comparison
bp has been promoted as soloist for a while now (individual instas/yts and tiktok for years, individual brand endorsments, individual variety attendances,..) while twice was always promoted as OT9 (?)
Nayeon might be one of the most popular twice members, she hasn't established her fan base enough yet to compare her with lisa or rose.
that being said, it would be insane if she does similar numbers.
I don't think it matters much?
Regardless however a group is promoted, the past years' experience teaches that solo releases usually make up around 60-70% of the group's release total.
Based on TWICE's last full album sales (890k?) and last EP sales (580k), Nayeon's sales might result somewhere between 400-600k.
But with the continuous annual album sales increases across the board, this might provide unexpected results like even higher sales.
She has worldwide/US distribution (+Target exclusive) unlike Chaelisa so she might be not be far from them, I think her hanteo number will be lower since her mini will be available on many stores and is also on Twice official store so fans don't have to use Ktown4u and other online stores that count for hanteo.
-
Lol yeh right in her dreams maybe
-
Lol yeh right in her dreams maybe
This is an example of why she won't I don't think. Her fans and fans of Twice are dominated mostly by Korean guys right? She's girlie and sweet and funny, she doesn't pretend to be a boss ass bitch like the BP girls, so she won't have the support of the outcast, friendless, loveless female kpop fans like the one I quoted.
Having said that, I think she'll be successful, hopefully even more depending of the quality of the music.
-
-
-
Depends on how good the tt is
Song quality rarely matters for sales. Groups are racking up tons of pre orders before teasers lol
-
Display More
not a once, but i don't think that's a fair comparison
bp has been promoted as soloist for a while now (individual instas/yts and tiktok for years, individual brand endorsments, individual variety attendances,..) while twice was always promoted as OT9 (?)
Nayeon might be one of the most popular twice members, she hasn't established her fan base enough yet to compare her with lisa or rose.
that being said, it would be insane if she does similar numbers.
logic is forbidden in KPOP you cannot do that here
we have to blindly demoralize the opposing team! who are the teams? anyone that aren't our favs!
-
-
It would be amazing if she outsold either considering they’ve had lots of solo promotion for years while she’s had basically none and their C-fanbases are massive and did a lot of bulk buying
Magazine covers aren't promotion and most of their sales also come from international fans not cbars solely and idk about outselling but nayeon should have no problem selling 500k plus first month since she has 4 standard versions and also global distribution like target exclusive versions for bb200 charting so US onces should be buying more
-
Participate now!
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!