So Twice do have individual popularity

  • Everyone and their mothers were trying to say it’s too late for them, they have no individual popularity anymore, they’re reliant on the TWICE brand, etc. but it seems they do have quite the individual popularity.

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.
  • I got a feeling that they are gonna start to have an akgae problem with this . I saw in the other thread other fans calling tzuyu overrated and saying that sana and other members are way more popular than her

  • All of them already surpassed most of these 4th gen IT girl personal insta in less than a day.

  • Why are you acting dumb? Obviously they have individual popularity, the question is: are they one of the most popular or just popular like any other kpop group hence proving yet again their decline?

  • Don't think anyone said some members are not pretty popular, just that they are behind blackpink

  • OP lacks reading comprehension. I don't think anyone has ever said they didn't have any individual popularity.

  • Why are you acting dumb? Obviously they have individual popularity, the question is: are they one of the most popular or just popular like any other kpop group hence proving yet again their decline?

    I'm pretty sure that after a couple of months all of the twice members will have more followers than every single female kpop groups except blackpink members. if you don't count that as one of the most popular girl groups then everyone under them are literal nugu, on decline, has been or barely popular.

    do note that some of the members already broke 3m+ followers, and it's not even 24hours since they made their accounts

  • Not sure when this started. Don't know if it was new kpop fans who didn't know any better or just that Twice was compared to BP (who have extremely strong individual fanbases). But anyone who claimed Twice didn't have individual popularity was so out of touch

  • I'm pretty sure that after a couple of months all of the twice members will have more followers than every single female kpop groups except blackpink members. if you don't count that as one of the most popular girl groups then everyone under them are literal nugu, on decline, has been or barely popular.

    do note that some of the members already broke 3m+ followers, and it's not even 24hours since they made their accounts

    We'll see and I said decline because they were the top gg, others have nothing to do with it.

  • We'll see and I said decline because they were the top gg, others have nothing to do with it.

    they are literally only behind blackpink

    if you're one of those top 1 or bust, then twice members are definitely not popular. with that logic, every single female kpop girl groups that the twice members beat in their followers' count are literal nugus.

    they will be around 10-15m+ (depends on which member) by the end of the year; then will break 20-25m+ in a year+ from now (assuming they all renew)

    hopefully, your other female kpop faves (not named blackpink) have more than that because it'll be embarrassing for them to be out followed by a 'declining, barely popular' twice member

  • they are literally only behind blackpink

    if you're one of those top 1 or bust, then twice members are definitely not popular. with that logic, every single female kpop girl groups that the twice members beat in their followers' count are literal nugus.

    they will be around 10-15m+ (depends on which member) by the end of the year; then will break 20-25m+ in a year+ from now (assuming they all renew)

    hopefully, your other female kpop faves (not named blackpink) have more than that because it'll be embarrassing for them to be out followed by a 'declining, barely popular' twice member

    They are on decline, next.

  • It's literally impossible for them to not have any individual popularity and I don't think anyone realistically said that either when they are like a 6 year old group who has sold millions of albums.


    Unless by "individual popularity" they meant like brand power or public influence? Because if that's the case then I kind of get what they mean. There are boy groups out there that probably have a shit ton of followers too, but outside of idol fans, no one probably cares all that much about them. We'd have to see how well they do with picking up individual cfs or if their solos actually chart high, or if they have any hit dramas.

  • It would be very difficult for Twice not to have enough individual popularity to surpass 3M followers on Instagram considering they have been active for 7 years and are the third biggest group internationally lol


    I disagree with people here saying they are only behind BP members (and there is a massive gap) in individual popularity though. Maybe they will end up with more Instagram followers than other female idols, but Instagram is a pretty stupid metric to rely on. Realistically, could any Twice members chart as well with a solo as Joy or Hwasa (until recently) in Korea)? Could they even chart as well as Yena, considering she's charting better than The Scientist and The Feels combined?

  • Not sure when this started. Don't know if it was new kpop fans who didn't know any better or just that Twice was compared to BP (who have extremely strong individual fanbases). But anyone who claimed Twice didn't have individual popularity was so out of touch

    Due to JYP's denial of individual careers for TWICE members, in brand and popularity rankings the TWICE members consistently and structurally rank lower than their position of TWICE the group would make you expect, with the individual TWICE members often coming up lower in those brand/popularity rankings than a lot of other idols of other groups.


    TWICE members might have individual popularity, but is it comparable with the popularity they have as TWICE the group, or is the gap with other idols like BP far, far larger than the popularity gap between BP and TWICE as groups, in South Korea and internationally?

  • First Army's doing an abrupt u-turn on the irrelevance of Instagram, and now Once's lol


    I followed Sana, because of course. It's about time she officially claimed her throne as most popular member. JYP of old would not have allowed this. I think NMixx were supposed to be toe to toe with Aespa. That experiment failed, and they badly need Twice to renew their contracts. Clearly Twice know that too!

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!