Are credits listed in the order of which how much their contribute?

I think so.

Honestly no idea, some people seems to think so

i dont think so in KOMCA the order is totally different tho

Quote from jinaland

i dont think so in KOMCA the order is totally different tho

but how to measure who has contributed most?

Quote from jinaland

but how to measure who has contributed most?

It's always your bias who contributes the most

Quote from icyruios

So I went to search since you mentioned it and I'm curious too. I just searched for 2 of their title tracks and it kinda does seem to be in the same order? The names of Day6 are listed first (although not in the exact same order), then followed by Hong Jisang (their main producer)

I wonder how they actually determine it. In the credits I shown in the OP it always seem to be Jae, Sungjin, Young K, Wonpil but in this it seems to be in alphabetical order? But even for KOMCA even if it is in alphabetical order, Hong Jisang who starts with H still appear after Day6 members whose names starts with J or P so I think there is a reason to it?

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

Display More

idk when i have searched up other songs the order was different in wiki & KOMCA

no idea how they write the credits

Quote from icyruios

So I went to search since you mentioned it and I'm curious too. I just searched for 2 of their title tracks and it kinda does seem to be in the same order? The names of Day6 are listed first (although not in the exact same order), then followed by Hong Jisang (their main producer)

I wonder how they actually determine it. In the credits I shown in the OP it always seem to be Jae, Sungjin, Young K, Wonpil but in this it seems to be in alphabetical order? But even for KOMCA even if it is in alphabetical order, Hong Jisang who starts with H still appear after Day6 members whose names starts with J or P so I think there is a reason to it?

pasted-from-clipboard.png

pasted-from-clipboard.png

Display More

I think it might be in order of the Komca number or something. Even for BTS Komca credits are not in the same order as what BH provides which is in order of who contributed the most.

komca list credits in order of the id not participation (number in brackets)

wikipedia isnt always accurate. You can usually check the credits (by contribution) in the album booklet

there's no proof yet. Check this up - https://gearspace.com/board/mu…ermined-song-credits.html

In the Korean alphabet, 'H' is at the end, so KOMCA is listing the names alphabetically.

Quote from Vivi1388

komca list credits in order of the id not participation (number in brackets)

wikipedia isnt always accurate. You can usually check the credits (by contribution) in the album booklet

Basically. Komca doesn’t use order or contribution. The best way to check credit contribution is the album booklet.

The only word I learned from this song was "heater."

Here is an example

976A9925-7F68-4D0E-941F-DEECADDC6B00.jpeg

Above is tear booklet credits

Below is komca

2917E53B-CEF1-4719-95EE-3BCCD49482F2.png

Isn't it wikipedia? You shouldn't rely on it at all. Tbh in terms of credits you shouldn't rely on anything other than KOMCA and credits in physical album, even melon have mistakes. In BTS' case tho the information in their official soundcloud is also reliable since their free work doesn't go with physical copy. And as for order, then in KOMCA no, credits aren't given in order, but in physical album yes, they're given like that and also keep in mind that 1st line is for those who participated in production, 2nd line is for those who participated in composing and writing lyrics.

pasted-from-clipboard.png