did Irene deserve to lose her IT status over one attitude controversy?

Imagine how bad the temper tantrum was that even the threat of an audio recording (not visual) was enough to scare SM into immediately forcing Irene to apologize. Most likely she was coming off as borderline unhinged in it.

It's one thing to read about someone losing it and going on a tirade. Putting it on speaker for the entire world to hear, for all the poor souls who endure that kind of verbal abuse day in and day out at home, at work, at school, to hear full force and relive those terrible moments... Irene is lucky. Very very lucky.

she ruined her career not because of the public opinion but because nobody wants to work with her

You've gotta love all the opportunistic Irene haters jumping in to say things like she was never an "it girl," which is blatantly & comically false, or acting like they were there and saw it all go down in-person, when in reality none of us even know for sure what happened or what was said.

Literally all we have is the stylist's word and an apology. That's it. Zero material documentation of the exchange ever surfaced. No one else ever chimed in beyond liking the stylist's post, which could have just been a generic show of support for all we know, and not a "OMG I hate her too!" That's your own interpretation, nothing more. Y'all just imagined all that crap about the whole industry outing her as a mega bitch with a terrible reputation. That only happened in your own imaginations.

Was the stylist telling the truth with no exaggeration? We don't know. Was Irene's apology a sincere admittance of guilt or something SM told her to say for the sake of damage control, just to get it over with? We don't know. Did she actually go on a legit abusive tirade or is the stylist just too sensitive and misunderstanding? We don't know. Has anyone else ever had a similar experience with her? We don't know.

The moral of the story is to stop acting like you know, because you don't. Appointing yourself judge & jury for something you know nothing about is prime troll behavior.

PS: She wasn't even blacklisted. She's still a popular member of a highly successful girl group and has even had a solo magazine shoot since then. LOL

imagine stanning an adult who made a staff cried in front of other staffs lol i can't relate .

she can act all nice on her new program with her staff, i don´t buy it, even she treats HER STAFF well, maybe she is not so nice with other people. I SEEN fancams where she was all bad attitude, even suprised her own memebers. She think she IS a Diva, and needs to learn she is just a Pretty face that can follow a choreo.