Is seventeen now the top 2 3rd gen boy group?

No

No

Still no, no need to ask this every week.

almost out of top 90 on melon daily on its second day.

It's looking bad or them, even nct with sticker and glitch mode which weren't well received managed to chart way higher

No and they have plateaued. Outside of their established fandom - they have no buzz

No, they only third by default coz the rest of 3rd gen boy groups are nugus.

Seventeen is this successful group that no one knows about

I dont think so

sorry but nope

their sales are impressive for sure but I'm not sure everything else matches

almost out of the top90 on melon on the second day & couldn't even enter spotify200 on the first day when even 4th gen groups can...

no, they aren't top 2

Quote from Deep-Fried Corn Studded DooDoo (183)

almost out of the top90 on melon on the second day & couldn't even enter spotify200 on the first day when even 4th gen groups can...

no, they aren't top 2

They aren’t even out melons top 20 yet nor melon top 60s, idek where you got “almost out of top 90”

Ppl will do anything to undermine them

Ppl here love to undermine them, ask about them in Asia where it’s their play ground the response would be much different than this western forum that for some reason enjoys undermining them

Quote from Blanched Ginger & Honey Mammoth (208)

Ppl here love to undermine them, ask about them in Asia where it’s their play ground the response would be much different than this western forum that for some reason enjoys undermining them

??? That still doesn't make them no.2 3rd gen bg lol

Quote from Cured Saffron & Shallot Beef (737)

No and they have plateaued. Outside of their established fandom - they have no buzz

That’s a great way to say it. They have plateaued. They aren’t having any geometrical growth and that’s ok. They have an established fanbase to have a long career

Quote from Blanched Ginger & Honey Mammoth (208)

They aren’t even out melons top 20 yet nor melon top 60s, idek where you got “almost out of top 90”

Ppl will do anything to undermine them

Check the daily charts, the one that matters and where they are performimg like a 4th gen bg. Anyone can chart in top 20 Real Time chart, it's even low for them to not be at least top 10 the first two days of release considering how it's easier now

Quote from Deep-Fried Corn Studded DooDoo (183)

almost out of the top90 on melon on the second day & couldn't even enter spotify200 on the first day when even 4th gen groups can...

no, they aren't top 2

They didn't enter Spotify 200? Yikes

They even came back 00h EST

I think nct I'd the number 2 3rd gen followed by 17.

Who is no. 2 then?