Posts by Cold_Wave

if jyp girl groups were releasing miss A type of music they would be doing a lot better.

maybe not great but better at least

who said what?

i don't know what youre trying to say here

maybe past jyp. jyp songs these days are weird...

Time to buy a rosé badge

checked australia spotify and she's #1. then i checked dynamite, butter, seven and cupid and they never reached #1. might be first kpop to reach the top spot? its her home country too so thats cool

gdragon about to untease his teasers

its heading that way

273k now. pretty good

ok youre wrong about a lot of things but thats the same list that i would have except i like new woman a bit more than apt

Quote from YamaChwan

Solar charted multiple songs in the top 20. At least one in the top 10. And these weren't even promoted singles. They were her solo directed and produced project "Solar's Emotion", which is still going to this day. She was the first Mamamoo member to chart multiple songs on MelOn.

Moonbyul sold the most albums, and her biggest hit was a top 20 song, "Selfish", featuring Seulgi.

So it's not like the unnie line has had no chart success, but the maknae line were the digital powerhouses.

To answer the question of this thread, globally, nobody has done what BP is doing.

In Korea, objectively speaking, no group has done what the Mamamoo members have yet, and they were the first.

Display More

Depends how you define it and how generous you want to be but I can't view the mamamoo members as successful soloists when the majority of their solo releases make no noise and don't chart. Especially compared to BP solo results it doesn't feel substantial at all.

With BP solo success were talking about ~1M album sales, 500M+ spotify streams and consistent top 10 korean charting (apart from Lisa).

Then we talk about mamamoo solo success and it's like "well she had a hit this one time 8 years ago." It's just very different levels of success.

Quote from YamaChwan

Mamamoo already did this, fam.

First and only third generation idols to get #1 hits on the Korean charts AND get a Perfect All-Kill. And TWO members did that.

So what did the other two do

Love New Woman

APT a close 2nd

Not really into spot

kinda has olivia rodrigo vibes

i like it. yena would hate it

Quote from YamaChwan

How Sweet debuted higher on MelOn and has spent several more weeks in the Melon Weekly Top 10, so...NewJeans did in fact do better, at least on the Korean charts.

week 20 super shy's digitals are stronger than week 20 how sweet so i think the melon position has more to do with the timing. how sweet did way worse in the US, japan and international in general so yeah its fair to say how sweet is a lot weaker overall

it could still do really well even if it doesnt do as well as magnetic. its hard to do better than magnetic, that was a super shy level hit. did nj flop when they never did as good as super shy afterwards?

Quote from atropos

Song will be released on 1st november? Or in 1 day

External Content x.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

or the song is 1 minute long

every other picture and video of her that day looked super good. its like getty went out of their way to get a picture her while the lighting was bad

nvm

Quote from YamaChwan

I never said that actually.

I always had a feeling Supernova was going to be huge.

You did predict aespa would chart well but when you learnt newjeans was actually releasing first you then said this:

Quote from YamaChwan

Is it too late to walk back this thread a bit? I was too lazy to check the release date for aespa's new album, and I thought they'd have a few days of charting before NewJeans return.

Oops.

Well, maybe I don't need to. Like I said earlier, the comeback can still be huge even if they get crushed by NewJeans.