Posts by proud-fan

Quote from huytienlam

Her solo will be a big success, I am sure, even if the song is "bad", it just needs to be badass.

On The Ground didn't do as well as Solo in Korea but slayed the international game.

Lisa will surely win internationally, and in Korea, I think it will do well too.

OTG was not as big as Solo but with the chart reform it entered, it did extremely well. It was the biggest solo from a idol soloist in the chart. Internationally, it was bigger though.

Lisa will surely do extremely well internationally as she is the most famous in BP. But SK is still questionable since she is not as famous as Rosé is in SK. And even though BR ranking is not to be used as a measure for an idol's popularity in SK, it can still give you the idea of how idols are known in SK. With the latest BR ranking, Lisa got a low rank despite the news of her solo.

So whether it might be a good song or not, Lisa's SK charting will not be assuring for now. It might chart around Top 20-25 since the chart right now is easier to penetrate compared to 24hits. I just hope it won't be in English so that it will gain more support from the gp.

Quote from nana18

But Rosé solo song was in English and she did amazing so I don't know what's the problem here ?

I think the difference is that Rosé is much more famous in SK than Lisa is. She is after all considered as SK's golden voice. An English song from Lisa will might not help her gain the gp.

Top 20 - 25 if not higher

Quote from kukukaka26

Stunning!! I think she's a really good editorial model

Yes. She's one of the best if not the best editorial model in Kpop. I feel so proud that she was able to improve her modelling. After her photoshoot with David, she seems to do modelling greatly.

T-ara

Quote from bbgc

Physicals?

Isn't it well established by now, that it is primarily the fans, who will never ever even unpack the album, don't even have a player to play, who will buy albums, out of loyalty to the idol, irrespective of the music.

Larger the fandom, more such buys.

Idols aren't complaining.

Nevertheless a far better indicator of a song's success is digital ULs.

And IU is unshakeable on the initial ULs, and pretty strong in longevity.

800K plus first 24 hr ULs, for Celebrity

Rose did 400K plus, that's pretty good, but doesn't surpass IU.

Wonder if Lisa can surpass Rose?

Display More

When it comes to SK charting, I honestly believe Lisa won't surpass Rosé. For a rookie soloist, Rosé did 400k ULs when other top girl groups weren't able to do this year.

But maybe in international charting and sales, she might surpass Rosé. With BBH100, with bigger sales, she might chart higher than Rosé. With BB Global 200 and BB Global 200 Exc. US, she won't since Rosé got #1 on those charts. They might have the same ranking there. In China, she might surpass Rosé since she's more famous there.

Anyway, when it comes to international, Lisa might surpass Rosé but not in SK.

Quote from Cold_Wave

There's no replay button for album sales and Rosé easily outsold.

I just can't help but laugh at OP's comment about Rosé's solo. She did extremely well for a rookie soloist and an English song.

Quote from haj1ma

Rose solo didn't surpass any of the female solos artists I mentioned

Kpop stans need to learn how to differentiate between abusing the replay button on YouTube and actual recognition and impact.

OTG peaked at #3 while Gone peaked at #5. Taeyeon's a digital monster but this year, she didn't do as well as she did before. Even Hyuna and Sunmi's comeback didn't do as well as they did before.

Only IU Rosé didn't surpassed in SK charting. But internationally and sales, she surpassed IU.

SK charting? No.

Internationally(West, China, SEA) charting? For sure.

Physical and digital sales? Yes

Dreamcatcher is growing. They deserve this so much. 👏👏👏

Quote from demonjo

It gave us so many beautiful examples of why Rosé is such a good singer while carrying her incredible charm

This video has all her covers in the show (today's ones included) with the timestamps inside, it's such a trip i love it

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Display More

One of the best thing that happened to Rosé this year.

Quote from DMV2DMZ

I think nurturing might be better than pushing. Pushing doesn't work for everyone.

I have to agree with that.

Jiyeon is and will always be my ultimate bias in Kpop despite what happened to her and the group. And just like Jiyeon, T-ara will always be my ultimate Kpop group.

Quote from DMV2DMZ

If the songs Rosé covered are any indication of her potential, she could grow into something really special for YGE.

There is such a huge potential in Rosé honestly. She just needs the push that will bring that potential out.

Different takes on the song that are all great but Rosé's was so good to me because it highlighted her vocal color. She really needs to sing an OST.

Rosé really needs an OST. Her cover of Nell's song was so good.

OTG and Gone over Dumb Dumb any day.

Chase Me

Scream

Deja Vu

Fly High

Piri

You and I

No More

Eclipse

Endless Night

Breaking Out

Good Night

Over the Sky

Boca

Odd Eye

What

Full Moon

Because

Rose Blue

I cannot wait for their comeback. Let's go, Queens!

SNSD takes the cake.

-Taeyeon, Jessica, Tiffany, Seohyun, and Sunny(vocals)

-Hyoyeon, Yuri, Sooyoung, and Yoona(dance)

-Sooyoung, Yoona, Yuri, Seohyun and Tiffany(acting)

-Hyoyeon and Sooyoung(rap)