Which Aespa member do you think is the most charismatic on stage/best performer?

Not the best dancer, singer or rapper.

Charisma. Charismatic. Performer.

Good on stage, has good expressions, conveys the feelings well despite maybe not being the best dancer etc.

Who is it for you?

NingNing

Idk Winter maybe?

Karina and Ningning hast the most charismatic visuals but Winter has better stage presence.

Karina and Ningning

then i would say Giselle (i think she's really underrated because people don't usually watch her fancam, but she's one of the only member who usually interact with fans when she's on stage)

and last i would say Winter, i love all the members but i must admit that Winter is the most boring to watch on stage for me

Karina always pops off!

Giselle or Winter I remember watching the aespa debut stage and they were a lot more expressive I don’t know why sm told them to stop

I'm sorry I love her but NingNing has n stage presence, she's pretty on stage that's all

Giselle and Winter are certainly the most

Karina is a hit or miss

I'm gonna disagree with the user above and say that for me it is actually Ningning who is the most charismatic on stage and has the most stage presence

While Winter and Karina always look just cold

winter

Ningning and winter. I like nining more.

Quote from OP

I'm gonna disagree with the user above and say that for me it is actually Ningning who is the most charismatic on stage and has the most stage presence

While Winter and Karina always look just cold

Yes ning got stage presence, winter looks cold but I like her dancing.

Either Ningning or Winter

my eyes stray to Gisele and Ningning

It's interesting people say giselle and i find her the least interesting on stage, she looks like she's bored and don't want to be there.

Ningning is my fave but she has no stage presence. I'm neutral about winter but she's the best on stage. Karina is meh. She's center and imo if she had stage presence they wouldn't look as lifeless on stage.

Imo none in txt have stage presence except for yeonjun and having him on stage improves their performances a lot. Aespa doesn't have that one member to make their performances exciting.

aespa has no stage presence at all but they had some way back during their debut performances and NL mushows.

During those days-

Ning/ Winter- best stage presence out of all.

Karina- hit or miss. Sometimes her expressionless face works but sometimes it's overused.

Giselle- she only shines in MV due to her iconic lines.

Ningning and Winter