Why do most Red Velvet Rnb songs flop (while NewJeans smashed)?

Red Velvet Rnb songs like Be Natural, Automatic, Really Bad Boy flopped in the charts yet NewJeans, who is said to have a similar sound to Red Velvet, can smash the charts?

rv are more known for their pop songs and they do it very well unlike aespa who are unable to come out with music that isn't disjointed and awful #onehitwonders

rv are 8 years into their careers and are still pumping out hits

aespa already showing a HUGE decline in their 2nd year

RV walked so MHJ's bootleg version of them could run.

Obviously RV had to try all R&B sounds because there was no mainstream kpop group before who tried it. They had to take risks and flop for years to finally find the successful formula with Bad Boy and Psycho and keep their integrity. NewJeans just came and rehashed what RV already made successful with years of effort.

RV vocalizes too much it's less easy to sing alone with comparable to New Jeans.

Quote from Oppa Gangnam Style (353)

rv are more known for their pop songs and they do it very well unlike aespa who are unable to come out with music that isn't disjointed and awful #onehitwonders

rv are 8 years into their careers and are still pumping out hits

aespa already showing a HUGE decline in their 2nd year

does this have to do anything with aespa???

those songs aren’t as catchy and refreshing as new jeans’

Quote from BADA BING BADA BOOM (136)

RV walked so MHJ's bootleg version of them could run.

Obviously RV had to try all R&B sounds because there was no mainstream kpop group before who tried it. They had to take risks and flop for years to finally find the successful formula with Bad Boy and Psycho and keep their integrity. NewJeans just came and rehashed what RV already made successful with years of effort.

guys did you know Red Velvet invented RnB? RV PAVED THE WAY

Attention sounds better than both Be natural and especially Automatic (not to mention Attention’s mv and concept is far more appealing and refreshing and less stuffy to watch) so its charting better should be a surprise to no one except willfully obtuse fools lol

Quote from Stage Presence Checker (99)

does this have to do anything with aespa???

it doesn't have to since were in anons

it's a rule to mention aespa flopping in any threads as karma for MYs being insufferable before girls

This thread is refreshing. Felt like I gargled with mouthwash.

newjeans got the rv velvet rejects with inferior vocals. But hey good for them, at least they will have more success than rv.

Timing is never on Red Velvet's side.

Be Natural came out while SM was basically burning out

Automatic came out in the summer and ICC was just more favorable a title

RBB is an acquired taste

Quote from Finna Find My Time (318)

Timing is never on Red Velvet's side.

Be Natural came out while SM was basically burning out

Automatic came out in the summer and ICC was just more favorable a title

RBB is an acquired taste

automatic and icc actually came out in spring, not summer. but icc should smash anyway because it’s way better than automatic