So were Shawols lying this whole time about Min Heejin?

  • idk what to believe anymore tbh


    External Content twitter.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.


    External Content twitter.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.


    shawols made it sound like she was on the set herself directing the entire photoshoot

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.
  • shinee was already targeting the noona since their debut with their debut song. idk how that is mhj’s fault. they should blame sm instead

  • shinee was already targeting the noona since their debut with their debut song. idk how that is mhj’s fault. they should blame sm instead

    People have always blamed SM, not only for this but for every similar incidents. I witnessed the rage directed at the Sherlock photoshoot, the View MV, Yeri in ICC MV etc, it was always directed at SM as a whole.

    The rage is now directed at MHJ because hybe media played about her being a former art director at SM and used it as a selling point while making her the face of the new group. She went from a nameless staff member behind the scenes - protected from fans rage by anonymity- to the face of the company.

  • People have always blamed SM, not only for this but for every similar incidents. I witnessed the rage directed at the Sherlock photoshoot, the View MV, Yeri in ICC MV etc, it was always directed at SM as a whole.

    The rage is now directed at MHJ because hybe media played about her being a former art director at SM and used it as a selling point while making her the face of the new group. She went from a nameless staff member behind the scenes - protected from fans rage by anonymity- to the face of the company.

    Who they blame then? When it's an SM artist, SM Production, SM music etc

  • People have always blamed SM, not only for this but for every similar incidents. I witnessed the rage directed at the Sherlock photoshoot, the View MV, Yeri in ICC MV etc, it was always directed at SM as a whole.

    The rage is now directed at MHJ because hybe media played about her being a former art director at SM and used it as a selling point while making her the face of the new group. She went from a nameless staff member behind the scenes - protected from fans rage by anonymity- to the face of the company.

    Hybe don't need to media-play because kfans already know who she is and they were the ones hyping her up, especially those old sm stans. they praised her to high heaven before the scandal blew up.

  • Hybe don't need to media-play because kfans already know who she is and they were the ones hyping her up, especially those old sm stans. they praised her to high heaven before the scandal blew up.

    There were many SM stans who praised her but there were also many who disliked and bashed her.


    Saying that hybe didn't media play about her past affiliation with SM and use it as a selling point is a huge lie. The huge majority of the kpop fandom had no idea who she was until she joined hybe, because hybe made it into a big deal. By consequences, people now have a face to direct their criticisms at instead of just throwing it at the company as a whole like it mostly was when she was still in SM.

  • There were many SM stans who praised her but there were also many who disliked and bashed her.


    Saying that hybe didn't media play about her past affiliation with SM and use it as a selling point is a huge lie. The huge majority of the kpop fandom had no idea who she was until she joined hybe, because hybe made it into a big deal. By consequences, people now have a face to direct their criticisms at instead of just throwing it at the company as a whole like it mostly was when she was still in SM.

    maybe some bashed her on the international side but the amount of praises were much more., especially on the k-side.

  • maybe some bashed her on the international side but the amount of praises were much more., especially on the k-side.

    that's really not how i remember it going down. there were always criticisms from both sides, about infantalising idols and also about repetitive concepts. i had seen these criticisms before i even knew her name because these criticisms were thrown at SM as a company, aside from some f(x) and SHINee fans, most SM stans didn't even know her because she was more involved with those 2 groups.

    the difference now is her name is preceeding the products she is putting out and her fame is used to sell, so now people are coming at her personally instead of just criticising the company.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!