Karina coming for V's record in China. Insane?

  • Second album only and Karina already surpassed Jungkook, Lisa and coming for V when it comes to Chinese sales. Is this crazy?

    External Content twitter.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.
  • her cbar has been bulk buying those multiple 8 dollar digipacks

  • V china bar spent more money on 165k proof albums than that of 230k mots7. If it's about money spent then I don't think her bar is spending even half as his.

  • Her Chinese bar is doing the most.

  • 200k soon haters can cope :peperich:

  • her cbar has been bulk buying those multiple 8 dollar digipacks

    The 8 dollar one can’t be bulk bought and only one version each person can order. It’s so they can have a billboard record or something. I think the digipak you mean that is being bulk bought is the $12 one (unless there was a store discount deal like ktown digipaks which aren't even half of Karina’s cbar numbers, other stores like SM shop are selling it at 12 dollars).



    That being said, it’s unfair to compare to BTS albums because BTS albums are even more expensive than the old albums before discount deals. They’re more expensive than most artists so it’s idiotic to put make these lists comparing the number of sales.

  • Before someone corrects my previous post, I just checked the SM shop and the digipak is not $12 like I said but is $13.32. Lol one dollar difference but I fear I get called out for just approximating it.

  • Congrats! Should have posted this on the main! Why are all aespa threads posted on anon?

  • aepsa ending even bts's album sales now? no wonder people are threatened

  • nice!! but album revenue > amount of sales

  • Like BTS aren't selling their new albums for 50$. Mots 7 is a 2020 album

  • shouldn’t this record be broken like years ago? sm is focusing in china anyways… hmm


    also, how much is those bts albums versus aespa albums?

  • wow no wonder antis are pressed in anons

  • the album costs $ 8 is that even comparable to the other people she supposedly surpassed

  • the album costs $ 8 is that even comparable to the other people she supposedly surpassed

    Cbars buying it on another site because Ktown sales has been increased slowly so your theory has been debunked they bought in normal price $ 13

  • oh wow 5 dollar difference, crazy...

    ... crazy that the point still stands. Bts album prices are usually $30-40

    Wrong, can't you do fact check?

    Bts MOTS album on ktown: $19 and $12 with discount.

    https://www.ktown4u.com/fanc_iteminfo?mst_fanc_goods_no=48149


    Aespa Girls album photobook: $16 and $13 with discount

    https://www.ktown4u.com/iteminfo?goods_no=79567

    Digipack; $12 normal price, $9.79 with discount

    https://www.ktown4u.com/iteminfo?goods_no=79560


    I don't see the big difference in prices especially considering the bts albums had more discount on preoder period and that's how cbars got the record

  • Why are haters comparing prices? Shouldn't all other gg members have this amount of sales if their albums are cheap as well? Also comparing the most popular boygroup debuted almost 10 years ago to a rookie girlgroup, like just admit you don't want to give them credit for this.

  • Why are haters comparing prices? Shouldn't all other gg members have this amount of sales if their albums are cheap as well? Also comparing the most popular boygroup debuted almost 10 years ago to a rookie girlgroup, like just admit you don't want to give them credit for this.

    Exactly, like I promise no one is going to combust if they admitted this was a neat achievement for a rookie girl and then move on with their life.

  • V bar spent the most money any china bar has ever spent for 165k proof albums which are less than both more albums. I'm sure karina bar hasn't spend even half of that to get these 170k sales. She sold more than lisa only because those were lisa's 2020 sales. Lisa bar spent more than karina bar for lesser sales. Aespa are selling albums for mediaplay. They are not getting any money for them. That's why sm can't make profits even after their artists selling so much.

  • You can't compare. YG and especially Hybe for BTS albums don't sell their for a bargain. It's still a nice number but let's not get carried away with obvious SM inflated sales for mediaplay

  • from now on we shouldnt count how many albums were sold but how much money fans spent on it

    yall sound so pressed its srlsy funny

  • V bar spent the most money any china bar has ever spent for 165k proof albums which are less than both more albums. I'm sure karina bar hasn't spend even half of that to get these 170k sales. She sold more than lisa only because those were lisa's 2020 sales. Lisa bar spent more than karina bar for lesser sales. Aespa are selling albums for mediaplay. They are not getting any money for them. That's why sm can't make profits even after their artists selling so much.

    SM can't make profits yet they're the second biggest kpop agency as of right now, will probably return to no.1 in some ~40 years

  • V bar spent the most money any china bar has ever spent for 165k proof albums which are less than both more albums. I'm sure karina bar hasn't spend even half of that to get these 170k sales. She sold more than lisa only because those were lisa's 2020 sales. Lisa bar spent more than karina bar for lesser sales. Aespa are selling albums for mediaplay. They are not getting any money for them. That's why sm can't make profits even after their artists selling so much.

    Vbar spent 3.5 million $ how much karina bar spend?

  • all i know is bp and bts albums ain’t cheap like sm acts :pepe-cringe:

  • all i know is bp and bts albums ain’t cheap like sm acts :pepe-cringe:

    It’s not “SM acts” and more the current industry. Sm acts actually have reasonable prices compared to some 4th groups (not that the groups are that different). All you guys fuss about with aespa is ktown4u sales which is usually a place with huge discounts. BP the album had discounts there as well like $12 standard price. They had expensive versions as well but aepa also has 40+ dollars versions too but everyone ignores that and focuses on cheap vers plus the discount. BP still has reasonable prices though. Lisa and Rose compared to The album


    Even BTS Jhope has discount right now.

    External Content twitter.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.



    Ktown4u usually sell for international fans. Have insane discounts but compensates in very expensive shipping. Korean fans even Chinese fans prefer to order from other places because Ktown rep is bad there.

  • It's funny how lies scalate so fast in kpop forums. Suddenly yg and hybe are the only companies not selling cheap albums when that's been that case since years ago and they proved it this year with lesserafim, txt, ikon and treasure releases. Not even bts and bp are safe, as it can be seen above, j hope solo and bp solos were getting discounts as much as any other kpop act and some of their group albums like MOTS were selling for as much as an aespa photobook

  • This thread contains 29 more posts that have been hidden for guests, please register yourself or login to continue reading.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!