Karina has the highest cbar of 4th gen

Aespa are doing the most ngl will she reach 100k alone the suspense

I thought Wonyoung bar bought like 91k or something like that. And shouldn't Rosé be leading this considering her bar bought over 350k for her solo

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (527)

I thought Wonyoung bar bought like 91k or something like that. And shouldn't Rosé be leading this considering her bar bought over 350k for her solo

Yeah rose bar preorder 160k for her solo

These are only group preorders. Why must have brought 98k but not preordered it

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (527)

I thought Wonyoung bar bought like 91k or something like that. And shouldn't Rosé be leading this considering her bar bought over 350k for her solo

Wonyoung's bar preordered only 48k i think, but they kinda lied and said it's 98k - that's why karinabar has beef with them. Wy bar put the total sales from them for love dive instead of just the preorders.

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (527)

I thought Wonyoung bar bought like 91k or something like that. And shouldn't Rosé be leading this considering her bar bought over 350k for her solo

it's just preorder numbers

Wonyoung bar bought 91K overall not just in preorder

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (527)

I thought Wonyoung bar bought like 91k or something like that. And shouldn't Rosé be leading this considering her bar bought over 350k for her solo

Don't know how true that is (the WY bar)

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (527)

I thought Wonyoung bar bought like 91k or something like that. And shouldn't Rosé be leading this considering her bar bought over 350k for her solo

Jang Wonyoung China bar fully announced to have bought 98,350 copies for LOVE DIVE and officially become TOP 1 seller of all 4th gen female idols bar.

People defo underestimate the aespa girls. They're not even in their 2nd year and they're already competing and besting Wonyoung and Sakura who've been in kpop for years

So wait. There is a record for pre-order and then a record for total sales?

Shouldn't the total sales be given main priority? I don't see how the preorder record is even that important.

Imagine arguing because of preorder records

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (527)

So wait. There is a record for pre-order and then a record for total sales?

Shouldn't the total sales be given main priority? I don't see how the preorder record is even that important.

Imagine arguing because of preorder records

it's interesting to see how loyal or how cbars go for their idols. If they get a high preorder they get a high total sales from cbar to. If Karina is able to reach 100k pre orders who knows what numbers she's getting for total sales

Quote from Oven-Grilled Apple & Lavender Boar (932)

People defo underestimate the aespa girls. They're not even in their 2nd year and they're already competing and besting Wonyoung and Sakura who've been in kpop for years

I second this but without the shade lol

That's not up to date, that was 14 hours ago. There should be an updated one soon Karina is a goddess

Quote from Oven-Grilled Apple & Lavender Boar (932)

People defo underestimate the aespa girls. They're not even in their 2nd year and they're already competing and besting Wonyoung and Sakura who've been in kpop for years

So when did the Aespa girls debut? This year?

Quote from Pickled Mint & Orange Bear (555)

So when did the Aespa girls debut? This year?

Oct 2020 - 2021 = 1 year

Oct 2021 - 2022 = 2 year

They are still in their first year, simple maths

Karina bar got those numbers in a span of 3 days after preorders opened and aespa still has a month to go before preorders end… that’s only from one store 

Quote from Pressure-Cooked Salted Pigeon (79)

Wonyoung's bar preordered only 48k i think, but they kinda lied and said it's 98k - that's why karinabar has beef with them. Wy bar put the total sales from them for love dive instead of just the preorders.

They did not lie. Just say you don't understand what pre-order means. Wonyoung bar pre-ordered 48k but in total they had a total ordered albums of 98k. There is a difference between pre-orders and albums that have actually been ordered.

Karina bar has beef with them because Karinabar is petty and childish and wants to invent records to make Karina sales look bigger than other 4th gen bars.

Quote from Oven-Grilled Apple & Lavender Boar (932)

People defo underestimate the aespa girls. They're not even in their 2nd year and they're already competing and besting Wonyoung and Sakura who've been in kpop for years

I don’t think they were ever underestimated in terms of their Chinese fanbase. We know SM caters to China like doing those pubg super idol league broadcasts. Cmiiw SSE don’t cater to China and focus on Korea and Japan recently.

Quote from Oven-Baked Nuts & Mammoth (858)

They did not lie. Just say you don't understand what pre-order means. Wonyoung bar pre-ordered 48k but in total they had a total ordered albums of 98k. There is a difference between pre-orders and albums that have actually been ordered.

Karina bar has beef with them because Karinabar is petty and childish and wants to invent records to make Karina sales look bigger than other 4th gen bars.

you just said what i had already typed but fancier? Blud

Quote from Oven-Baked Nuts & Mammoth (858)

Karina bar has beef with them because Karinabar is petty and childish and wants to invent records to make Karina sales look bigger than other 4th gen bars.

Karina is the most popular 4th generation idol in China, has million views on fancams, the most of the entire generation, her short hair gain 40 million+ views. it's not KarinaBar who buys massively, but chinese fans. she has locals there on chokehold. she's a popular individual there, just like everywhere except Japan. she is the most popular individually, just like everywhere except Japan.

Quote from Cured Saffron & Shallot Beef (557)

Karina is the most popular 4th generation idol in China, has million views on fancams, the most of the entire generation, her short hair gain 40 million+ views. it's not KarinaBar who buys massively, but chinese fans. she has locals there on chokehold. she's a popular individual there, just like everywhere except Japan. she is the most popular individually, just like everywhere except Japan.

Bruh, take a breath before you shit yourself. I was talking about in relations to the SALES. Not overall popularity. I'm not even on Weibo so I can't contest your manic claims nor do I have any interest to.

To get back on topic which is the reason of the beef. Wonyoung bar had a first pre-order of 48k. After they made the order, there was a surplus of people who wanted to order albums as well so they put out a second one which is why they ended up with 98k.

Karinabar went around ignoring this fact and accused Wonyoung bar of lying about the sales and pre-order and made tweets using only the pre-orders to undermine Wonyoung sales.