I was under the impression that the biggest gg bar after BP was Twice. Chinese reveluvs really went all out for this album.

We already know this. C-bars contribute a lot for SM acts.

Twice C-bars were never that huge. What the heck are u even saying?

It was never twice.

Twice never do such long term ebeggery

Natty sales only

Twice better streams tho

Queen Joy fans went all out

158k alone

Twice are like BTS in china. Big enough fandoms but a lot of groups easily outdo them there. Probably doesn't help that they have what are considered huge scandals in China.

Quote from Smoked Olive Boar (164)

Queen Joy fans went all out

158k alone

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Not SM stans trying to cover the fact that most of their sales are due to china c-bar sales

Quote from Fire-Grilled Casserole of Duck (687)

Not SM stans trying to cover the fact that most of their sales are due to china c-bar sales

And what is wrong with China c-bar sales? Is it fake sales or are they not counted on Goan. Or do they use fake currency to purchase them

Which is it?

Quote from OP

And what is wrong with China c-bar sales? Is it fake sales or are they not counted on Goan. Or do they use fake currency to purchase them

Which is it?

It's racism. They are trying to say that Chinese sales aren't worth as much as western sales.

Disgusting.

Quote from Dried Beets & Lemon Turkey (78)

It's racism. They are trying to say that Chinese sales aren't worth as much as western sales.

Disgusting.

They do the same thing with japan or sea sales/views

Wondering what's going on with c-bars. Last year they were prevented by CCP rom buying more than one copy of an album per person. Looks like they're finding ways to circumvent it. I hope they're not putting themselves in danger.

It's funny. People only have an issue with chinese fans when it's blackpink even when their % from china is smaller than SM groups

Quote from Fried Mint & Mustard Mutton (125)

It's funny. People only have an issue with chinese fans when it's blackpink even when their % from china is smaller than SM groups

? Did you skip over the persons in this very same thread who also have a racism-suspect issue with Chinese fans when it's SM groups?

Quote from Fire-Grilled Casserole of Duck (312)

They do the same thing with japan or sea sales/views

Yeah, typical western racism on display.

Same goes for the ongoing "international" success. They mean western, primarily US success.

They'll always discount sales and stats from Asian countries.

I didnt know rv has a lot of chinese fans

People who are reliant on 80% China sales are gonna have a lot of drags to deal with when they start touring again and they hitting up the rec' centers and bingo halls but 300 to 500 k albums vanishing into China lmao.

Quote from DooDoo Glazed Pork Chops (220)

People who are reliant on 80% China sales are gonna have a lot of drags to deal with when they start touring again and they hitting up the rec' centers and bingo halls but 300 to 500 k albums vanishing into China lmao.

Jealous stans of other groups will ALWAYS drag no matter what, using whatever excuse they can use to shade other groups and be a general party pooper cause they can't stand stans of other groups be happy celebrating their groups' successes.

Any reason they can find to act like a buzzkill and hate shader will be good enough, if it's not China then it's SEA if it's not SEA then it's 'local group' etc etc, there's always something. Best to simply ignore such jealous, petty people and negative nancies