EXO’s Cream Soda scores its first music show win on MUSIC BANK!!! #121st Win!!!

Quote from daniel-cruz

It marks their 121st trophy as a full group on music shows!

I've been tracking music show wins (see here), and I'm showing 116 wins for EXO prior to this latest comeback. Can you provide a full listing of the claimed 121 wins so we can examine the discrepancies?

LETS GOOOO, they were excluded from the prevote and still won!

Quote from daniel-cruz

That’s weird….why are there many different total number of wins? Makes no sense… I am not keeping track, I just posted what I saw with chart accounts….

External Content twitter.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

Ok, here are the discrepancies between that tweet and my data set:

Miracles in December – 10 wins versus 9 wins

This article shows 9 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_in_December_(song)

Overdose – 10 wins versus 8 wins

This article does show the 10 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overdose_(Exo_song)

However, this article states that no wins were awarded on Music Bank on May 16+23 2024 due to the Sewol disaster: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/…Bank_Chart_winners_(2014)

Monster – 10 wins versus 9 wins

This article shows 9 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monster_(Exo_song)

Thus, it looks like there are conflicting claims. Is there any proof to support these extra 4 wins?

WE ARE GETTING THAT ENCORE

Quote from wsoet

Ok, here are the discrepancies between that tweet and my data set:

Miracles in December – 10 wins versus 9 wins

This article shows 9 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_in_December_(song)

Overdose – 10 wins versus 8 wins

This article does show the 10 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overdose_(Exo_song)

However, this article states that no wins were awarded due to the Sewol disaster: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/…Bank_Chart_winners_(2014)

Monster – 10 wins versus 9 wins

This article shows 9 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monster_(Exo_song)

Thus, it looks like there are conflicting claims. Is there any proof to support these extra 4 wins?

Display More

no source but my anecdotal experience, but Monster definitely won "only" 9 times, I remember being disappointed we didn't get to 10 at the time. I remember when KKB got 11 wins I was like "nice, back to over 10 again as usual."

Quote from wsoet

Ok, here are the discrepancies between that tweet and my data set:

Miracles in December – 10 wins versus 9 wins

This article shows 9 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_in_December_(song)

Overdose – 10 wins versus 8 wins

This article does show the 10 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overdose_(Exo_song)

However, this article states that no wins were awarded due to the Sewol disaster: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/…Bank_Chart_winners_(2014)

Monster – 10 wins versus 9 wins

This article shows 9 wins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monster_(Exo_song)

Thus, it looks like there are conflicting claims. Is there any proof to support these extra 4 wins?

Display More

idk about others but i think for overdose they might have included 2 chinese global music show wins exo-m has won

Quote from redcurtain

no source but my anecdotal experience, but Monster definitely won "only" 9 times, I remember being disappointed we didn't get to 10 at the time. I remember when KKB got 11 wins I was like "nice, back to over 10 again as usual."

Ah that's good to know. Now I did locate this Korean Wikipedia article that lists an extra win on Dec 27 2013 (look for "12월의 기적 (총 9회)"), but then this English Wikipedia article states "No chart and winner" for that date. I can't find any proof that an additional win was ever handed out.

Quote from novemberrain

idk about others but i think for overdose they might have included 2 chinese global music show wins exo-m has won

Can you provide any additional sources for these Chinese awards?

From what I've seen, the discrepancy comes from two wins for "Overdose" that were supposedly handed out on May 16 2014 and May 23 2014. However, I know that Music Bank was cancelled for weeks during this time due to the Sewol disaster, and the show's official web site for posting win notifications didn't announce anything between April 13 2014 and May 30 2014.

Quote from wsoet

Can you provide any additional sources for these Chinese awards?

From what I've seen, the discrepancy comes from two wins for "Overdose" that were supposedly handed out on May 16 2014 and May 23 2014. However, I know that Music Bank was cancelled for weeks during this time due to the Sewol disaster, and the show's official web site for posting win notifications didn't announce anything between April 13 2014 and May 30 2014.

change 0 to o

https://www.s0ompi.com/article/610003wpp/exo-m-once-again-wins-no-1-on-global-chinese-music

Quote from novemberrain

change 0 to o

https://www.s0ompi.com/article…1-on-global-chinese-music

Ah thanks. So it is helpful to note that the article states the following: On May 17, EXO-K took home a trophy on MBC’s “Music Core” with their title track “Overdose,” following their wins on MBC Music’s “Show Champion” and MNet’s “M!Countdown.”

We'll notice that a win on Music Bank was not listed, despite all the other music shows receiving a mention.