I feel like Winter is wasted in aespa and would be better in NewJeans

Quote from jinaland

nah nj concept is too young for her

Well she looks cute and youtfull so i don’t think it would be a reach. She could pass.

Quote from itiswhatitisss

If she didn't fit the concept she wouldn't have become so popular. It's that simple. People don't talk about this but "fitting the concept" is absolutely essential to an idol's popularity, just look at Sakura when she was with IZ*ONE vs in LSFM.

Next Level & Savage era everyone was talking about her to so idgi

Her visuals and vocals provide a sort of breath of fresh air to the darkness/sharpness of the other girls' visuals & the overall concept imo

Yeah well the fact that she still shines in this concept is just a testament of her talent and charms.

Your Sakura comparaison is so well thought. It's almost a perfect example. Sakura is good in LSFM but she suited Izone concept much better. Even thought she is supposed to look more charismatic in LSFM she just shined brighter in Izone.

And i feel the same as well aboit Winter. She is not bad but she can do so much better and has a crazy muscial potential that i found to be wasted in aespa. Until now at last.

Quote from lidora

I think (as a non-fan) that Aespa is wasted as a whole. They have little content, their songs are too talk-rap heavy when they are good singers (and I'm sorry, but not really good rappers), they are in the dungeon so much I am beginning to think they are YG-artists, and their stages were badly made by SM, their choreos are not really fit for a good performance, their company created lip-sync scandals for them with their choices. The girls could do better if the company gave them the right content. IMO, of course. But as much momentum they had they are beginning to lose it.

Wow you perfectly pointed out all their flaws. Dang.