I laugh when yall exclude jimin from successful soloists convo

I'm putting my bets on him, guy is literally working with bts producers.

He's going to be the most successful one.

Show the numbers first, 2 solos out already and they were a flop.

Nowadays even if you sell over a million albums, you are considered a flop.

Quote from Boy Crush Concept (754)

Show the numbers first, 2 solos out already and they were a flop.

No Jimin's solo songs are hit on spotify and he has a decent Korean fandom.

Poor Jinnie .. such a flop after selling over 1million albums at $14 pax.. poor flopping boy gets to pocket couple of million dollars in this economy..tsk

Quote from Boy Crush Concept (754)

Show the numbers first, 2 solos out already and they were a flop.

what two solos???

Jimin only release With You on spotify

Quote from Energetic Anons Poster (204)

Nowadays even if you sell over a million albums, you are considered a flop.

Because the streams and download doesn't match with the album sales.

Quote from Energetic Anons Poster (204)

Nowadays even if you sell over a million albums, you are considered a flop.

Selling a million to a fandom before they even hear the music from said solo debut is not that impressive no. The fandom that initially buys is pretty much built off group work.

Quote from Boy Crush Concept (754)

Show the numbers first, 2 solos out already and they were a flop.

i KNOW you're not talking about jhope & jin?

one sold 500k with no physicals album, the other sold 1M+ in record time & both did better everywhere (hot100, global 200, BB japan, spotify charts,..) than any other ksoloists except for maybe 2/3 others..

except for kcharts - where almost no male idol (group) is really thriving atm - where did it flop?

unless you base succes on only kcharts, you don't consider any ksoloist succesful?

Quote from Happy Anons Poster (996)

i KNOW you're not talking about jhope & jin?

one sold 500k with no physicals album, the other sold 1M+ in record time & both did better everywhere (hot100, global 200, BB japan, spotify charts,..) than any other ksoloists except for maybe 2/3 others..

except for kcharts - where almost no male idol (group) is really thriving atm - where did it flop?

unless you base succes on only kcharts, you don't consider any ksoloist succesful?

It is about them. They have good numbers where fandom can help, but do they have stability? Longevity? And kcharts are important too, weren't them the biggest male idols there?

Who said he wasn't?

Quote from BLACKPINK Concert Evaluator (872)

Selling a million to a fandom before they even hear the music from said solo debut is not that impressive no. The fandom that initially buys is pretty much built off group work.

So Baekhyun selling a million is pretty muck based off group work too?

Stop giving time to fools who call BTS flop soloists even after they break all records. It is pointless, these people will always nitpick over BTS' success and keep making nee goal posts.

a few jhope and jungkook solo stans aren't 'yall'

Quote from Idol Interaction Analyst (601)

So Baekhyun selling a million is pretty muck based off group work too?

He didn't sell a million on his debut but yes. But to a much smaller extent as he had done his fair share of solo work beforehand.

Nayeon selling 500k for Twice for example is no different. No solo work or promotions beforehand and sells 500k off the bat. The sales weren't the impressive aspect of her debut at all, more so that the song itself did better than the group releases.