More relevant in 2022: Red Velvet or Twice?

    Both seemed to have faded in the background compared to 4th gen but who feels more relevant now?

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    Only one of them has a top 2 hit during their last cb and that’s Red Velvet who also outsold any of Twice’s first week sales on Hanteo by miles. Twice cant even use their physicals over RV now and their last cb peaked at 40 on melon… sad

    It’s Twice, 4th gen is way behind them.

    Reveluv's are so unintentionally hillarious. These replies would get laughed out of a room if this wasn't an anon.

    Quote from Main Dancer (246)

    Reveluv's are so unintentionally hillarious. These replies would get laughed out of a room if this wasn't an anon.

    I haven't seen a single reveluv on this forum for weeks

    Realistically RV, we know their members individually have been always more relevant than twice members and now in the music aspect twice hasnt been doing well while rv has been releasing good music and charting well.

    Quote from Main Dancer (246)

    Reveluv's are so unintentionally hillarious. These replies would get laughed out of a room if this wasn't an anon.

    and where’s twice success? they can’t even chary anymore and every single song done worse than last one since yes or yes

    Twice hasn't a CB yet.


    But if you look at the last few years is clearly RV. FMR while not exactly great charting had done much better than any Twice song for the last 3 years. Hell most ggs have done better than Twice

    Not an RV stan, or SM stan, or Big 3 stan.

    But now that TWICE have their comeback, I don't think it's weird or delusional to say Red Velvet seem to do better or be more relevant.


    Don't really agree with the OP that RV and TWICE have faded to the background. They're still around and I think RV charted very well with FMR?

    It's just that some of the 4th gen girl groups have really been slaying this year, even older 4th gen groups like IDLE (and well deserved, they're a really impressive group).

    Quote from RATATATA (630)

    Not an RV stan, or SM stan, or Big 3 stan.

    But now that TWICE have their comeback, I don't think it's weird or delusional to say Red Velvet seem to do better or be more relevant.


    Don't really agree with the OP that RV and TWICE have faded to the background. They're still around and I think RV charted very well with FMR?

    It's just that some of the 4th gen girl groups have really been slaying this year, even older 4th gen groups like IDLE (and well deserved, they're a really impressive group).

    Feel My Rhythm spent 10 weeks on Melon top 10.

    Twice couldn't last a day in the top 40.

    Quote from YG Dungeon Resident (762)

    Feel My Rhythm spent 10 weeks on Melon top 10.

    Twice couldn't last a day in the top 40.

    Twice with not a lick of promo is in the top 40 rn. The lies.

    External Content twitter.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

    Quote from Stage Presence Analyst (246)

    Twice with not a lick of promo is in the top 40 rn. The lies.

    External Content twitter.com
    Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
    Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.


    Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't that an hourly update? That's not the same as 'lasting for a day' in the top 40. I just checked, and Talk that Talk is at #48 on Melon daily.

    Doesn't mean it can't happen, that the song can still rise, after all TWICE comeback is just a few days ago and there are enough examples of songs that started slowly but rose to do great, like Next Level and Sneakers.


    It's untrue that they're not promoting though. They are promoting.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login