Would NewJeans' Attention have smashed if they come from a nugu label?

Let's say they don't come from Hybe or even big 3, would Attention have smashed on its own?

No big 4 group sing would have smashed the same what doesn’t click for u people

same as any big 4 group

In the past decade how many groups not from big 4 or produce have actually made a name for themselves at the top? A few dozens, out of tens of hundreds of groups that debuted. And a lot of nugus release music just as good as big 4 / produce groups. So luck is overwhelmingly important to break out. People asking questions like op is really just fishing for people to drag the group

No

but at the same time

Nmixx's debut proves that's far from the only factor

you damn well know the answer is no

they would be truly nugu

Quote from Dried Beets & Lemon Turkey (853)

No

but at the same time

Nmixx's debut proves that's far from the only factor

still a big factor. nugus ain't selling 400k or ranked inside top 100 for such a disastrous song

They would have been the most slept on because no one would have called their image and music fresh but called it boring

No, because a nugu label wouldn't have been able to move the mountain of cash required to get underground producer "250" to compose and arrange the songs.

That's before all the expensive promo.

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (42)

you damn well know the answer is no

they would be truly nugu

Same could be said about every single big4 group... There's literally NO big4 group that didn't benefit from their companies privilege

Quote from Oppa Gangnam Style (643)

No, because a nugu label wouldn't have been able to move the mountain of cash required to get underground producer "250" to compose and arrange the songs.

That's before all the expensive promo.

Lmao who is 250? Did anyone even know them?

Quote from Chicken Noodle Soup (470)

Lmao who is 250? Did anyone even know them?

cmon dude, be more obvious about you not having taste. Typical hallow kpoppie behavious

Quote from Chicken Noodle Soup (470)

Lmao who is 250? Did anyone even know them?

They're known about in the kpop hip-hop scene, as a very well regarded (and quite underground) producer. i can't help that you don't know them, but it's not surprising that a standard kpoppie has no idea who they are.

attention is a good song

but they wouldn`t get that hype without hybe

Quote from Chicken Noodle Soup (470)

Lmao who is 250? Did anyone even know them?

Let's be honest here Hybe has better pds.

honestly no

No since big companies are what help these groups get a bigger audience to check them out.

Although, the song wouldn't have been this big if it wasn't good. SK can check out the debuts from big companies but will they continue to listen to it if it's bad? Nope (O.O or WADADA are examples)

Honestly, their music is so-so.

People only hyped because they are from hybe and min hee-jin.

Quote from Dried Beets & Lemon Turkey (853)

No

but at the same time

Nmixx's debut proves that's far from the only factor

nmixx case is like an outlier i would say. how many groups debuted in big4 that wasn't 'successful' besides nmixx, and then how many got big. i'd rather sold 100k+ and deemed as failure in a big4 than nugus honestly lol.

how many nugus sale above 50k much less 100k+ ):