Karina’s China Bar 335,000 albums. Crazy?

    Quote from Seared Casserole of Venison (266)

    A c-bar is a like a fan club with tons of people, they just make a group order to cut down the shipping fees. It's not just a few people buying all of those albums lol, it's tons of people making their order through the c-bar.

    So how many were non-ship orders? And where is the group C-bar order?


    While I'm here, I'd like to add my fake concern now and leave.

    Quote from Broasted Confit of Mammoth (730)

    so does giselle contribute anything to the group besides controversies?

    Maybe not to non-MYs. But I personally appreciate the depth and balance she brings to their vocals in their songs. She's made some ignorant mistakes, and she's obviously the least trained and capable dancer, but she honestly seems like a really sweet girl if you watch their content. I think the hate and shade towards her is overkill, and she's unfortunately held to a higher standard because she's pretty fluent in English ( though wasn't born, schooled or grew up in the US). She'll improve over her career. I just hope all the vitriol doesn't destroy her confidence.

    So almost half of the sales are chinese and without even counting people who are part of of cbars. No wonder their streams are so bad

    Sorry MYs but we didn't make those numbers. Be mad at the cbars. Those are some cold hard facts slapping her in the face.

    It's not that she has so less fans than others. It's not comparable because it seems like her fans are not even trying because they know they aren't in the competition. Maybe they'll actually buy when it's something solely related to her.


    These kinds of numbers are not surprising. Just look at any other c-bar numbers for a full group. This difference is completely normal.

    Quote from Marinated Watercress Bear (316)

    is this physical albums? im always curious about this, like when fans buy bulk albums, im assuming they dont actually USE 350k albums...so where tf do all of it go? i understand if you buy 2-3 albums, sometimes they contain limited photo cards or something, but 350k? like who tf uses that?


    i always see crazy albums being sold so just really curious lol


    like if its going to the trash anyways, why dont companies do digital sales? so they save up on albums production? anyone can educate me?

    If the US, which has a population of 329M can sell 50k-100K of an album, why is it shocking that a country with a population of 1.4B can scape together a few hundred thousand people to buy albums? Even if each fan is putting in money to buy 10-20 albums (or even 100 albums) it’s not like it’s 5 fans buying 300K albums. LOL

    No wonder streams are low. They are heavily reliant on c-bars. They can’t even beat IVE.

    So 400k albums excluding China, this makes sense for the poor international streams. All their stans are in China

    Quote from Stir-Fried Mint Quail (269)

    Stop playing dumb. We know most of y'all hate Giselle so y'all can stop pretending you feel bad that she got the least sales. Get lost

    You are wrong. We don't hate her, we wonder why is she in the group. She brings nothing to it except english. Are we really at the point where only knowing a language is enough to become an idol? Karina has a better tone and is decent in rapping, she could have done all rapping parts by herself. Giselle is a filler member in a four member group. Not many cares about her hence the number above

    can you imagine how much better aespa might be doing if they had another stan attractor or a dance powerhouse instead of Giselle? talk about a wasted opportunity

    Quote from Pickled Mint & Orange Bear (370)

    You are wrong. We don't hate her, we wonder why is she in the group. She brings nothing to it except english. Are we really at the point where only knowing a language is enough to become an idol? Karina has a better tone and is decent in rapping, she could have done all rapping parts by herself. Giselle is a filler member in a four member group. Not many cares about her hence the number above

    Lol you just called this girl a filler and you're saying you bs aren't hating on her? You phony asses should at least own up to it. Don't care about but always got her name in y'all damn mouths

    Quote from Marinated Watercress Bear (111)

    So almost half of the sales are chinese and without even counting people who are part of of cbars. No wonder their streams are so bad


    Quote from Poached Light Beer Lamb (874)

    No wonder streams are low. They are heavily reliant on c-bars. They can’t even beat IVE.


    Quote from Deep-Fried Sour Ostrich (650)

    So 400k albums excluding China, this makes sense for the poor international streams. All their stans are in China


    Take away cbars contributions and WOW, Aespa are pretty much nugu.


    I was wondering why their streams are flopping so bad, now i know lol.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login