Ningning live vocals has improved so drastically it’s scary

Surprised no one has mentioned this. For a group that rarely sing lives aespa can sing so well. Winter is a prodigy, her live singing is one of the best in kpop and Karina is pretty good to but Ningning live singing has improved the most in such a short time. Well done to them. They are shaping up to be a great group the hate and criticism only makes them work harder it seems.

Ningning was great on Coachella. Her voice shook while she was talking to the crowd because she was nervous but the singing and especially high notes were better than pre-records.

sure but what is the point of being good at singing if they are not gonna show it off? they should be like mamamoo! confident at live singing and not using loud backtrack to blow everyone’s mind and aespa really need to work on their stage presence in my opinion

Good on them. Antis can suck it.

Ningning sounded great, but I'm even more impressed by Karina, she has such a strong voice and I love her voice timbre, it has a rawness or edge or something special to it.

improvment based on 2 live perfomances, their only ones in their careers, lol

Honestly, the only way to showcase how great they are is through singing on a show or solo songs that can really express their vocals and range, i.e Immortal Songs. Mamamoo did it, Red Velvet too. Got to know how great Wendy is during that show.

Winter's good, saw some snippets of her sometimes ago..

As singers, always great to improve. That's what real artists should strive for anyways.

Quote from Stir-Fried Mint Quail (769)

improvment based on 2 live perfomances, their only ones in their careers, lol

And they're still clearing your faves vocally ooh ik you mad