I don't think Bp will be able to outdo Tomboy in k-charts with their upcoming comeback

    Honestly Idle gonna end up with the biggest female artist song this year definitely after IU if the latter drops an album. They are having their Rolling moment. But not to worry blinks, bp gonna dominate everything else. So don't be sad if their k-charting isn't absolute stompage this year.

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    Probably, but also BP could hit bigger peaks in uls since they are releasing in summer with much more anticipation. Now in 2020 nonstop started way too ahead of HYLT, yet HYLT ended up being bigger by centimeters, LSG was released at the end of the year and it had a huge longevity which put it at the biggest 2020 gg release

    1. Why the BP comparison?

    2. Gidle - Tomboy and Brave Girls - Rollin aren't the same situation. Rollin was an old song that went viral and managed to become a national hit. Brave Girls are right now on the verge of becoming a one hit wonder. On the other hand Gidle has been one of the most popular girl groups for years now and released multiple popular songs before Tomboy. Tomboy is simply taking it one step further

    I swear stans have the memory of a goldfish. You think Blackpink have never done better? Tomboy was great, but let's not act like it took Korea by storm. Their fans self-dragged by demanding to know why chart stats accounts didn't report on Tomboy's roof-hits. It's because it had none. Compare that to Still Life which made no noise on stan twitter but is still racking up the real time roof-hits after a week.

    Yes, gidle for sure will be the best performing charting gg’s for this year for sure. This is why early year comeback is good and have an advantage, if the song is charting high on charts and doing good longetivity then it surey have more digital point than the late release which make them easily win awards at the end of the year. But like i said in other thread, PAK is huge achievement but it actually not the main focus one, the song need to have a good longetivity to make it have more impacts.

    Quote from OP

    Honestly Idle gonna end up with the biggest female artist song this year definitely after IU if the latter drops an album. They are having their Rolling moment. But not to worry blinks, bp gonna dominate everything else. So don't be sad if their k-charting isn't absolute stompage this year.

    IU mostly won't, but even just with the Pieces and Gandhara, she is already far ahead of all others in Gaon Digital points.


    Not sure if that's a criteria for the awards. But anyway.


    BP doing well or not, Tomboy has been a big deal for GIDLE.

    Twice won't be able to outdo tomboy. That's all we can say for sure right now

    If BP release a ddu du ddu part 5 sk will eat it up

    Quote from Basted Rice & Mammoth (281)

    1. Why the BP comparison?

    2. Gidle - Tomboy and Brave Girls - Rollin aren't the same situation. Rollin was an old song that went viral and managed to become a national hit. Brave Girls are right now on the verge of becoming a one hit wonder. On the other hand Gidle has been one of the most popular girl groups for years now and released multiple popular songs before Tomboy. Tomboy is simply taking it one step further

    No by Rolling moment, I meant Idle having a smash hit that's all.

    Quote from Breaded Honey Turkey (372)

    Twice won't be able to outdo tomboy. That's all we can say for sure right now

    I mean Twice kinda dropped the ball with korean gp but hey there albums have gotten better and they don't need mere charts to prove anything anymore. But you may never know either, what if they get a hit like old Twice with a summer song.

    Quote from Dry-Roasted Asparagus Mammoth (391)

    I swear stans have the memory of a goldfish. You think Blackpink have never done better? Tomboy was great, but let's not act like it took Korea by storm. Their fans self-dragged by demanding to know why chart stats accounts didn't report on Tomboy's roof-hits. It's because it had none. Compare that to Still Life which made no noise on stan twitter but is still racking up the real time roof-hits after a week.

    Can you not discredit Idle please

    Quote from OP

    Please god no, they need to switch it up, its tiring and its 2022, teddy needs to come up with something melodic, lsg was a nice change.

    i fully expect their next single/title track to follow teddy hype song formula to a T again cuz it always works so yeah D4 part 5.

    Yeah… I’ma just stay silent on this one

    omg people are so pressed with charts peaks.

    Tomboy can be how popular you want but gidle won't ever be half as popular as pb.

    And I'm saying this as casual fan.

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login