so giselle plagiarized and no one even cares

The "this is my palace, champagne on chalice" part is from Janelle Monae's Django Jane.

Dont even come with a "thats only one line" because that's a whole bar. And pls don't say she sampled it you can't sample a bar.

And don't come with "maybe she didn't know" because who the hell uses the word chalice?

Quote from OP

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content www.youtube.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

The "this is my palace, champagne on chalice" part is from Janelle Monae's Django Jane.

Dont even come with a "thats only one line" because that's a whole bar. And pls don't say she sampled it you can't sample a bar.

And don't come with "maybe she didn't know" because who the hell uses the word chalice?

Display More

Rappers do this all the time. It’s called intentionally making a reference to a popular work. If you listen to enough rap outside K-pop, you’ll know. You really think she wouldn’t consider the possibility of people looking up the lyrics?

It was a stylistic choice.

So you've been in a coma since October 2020? Cause this has been covered.

Quote from Deep-Fried Red Whine Bear (741)

Rappers do this all the time. It’s called intentionally making a reference to a popular work. If you listen to enough rap outside K-pop, you’ll know. You really think she wouldn’t consider the possibility of people looking up the lyrics?

It was a stylistic choice.

please mys were raving about ho great she is at writing and now that she copied someone else's bar, its a "stylistic choice"

even if its a stylistic choice you have to give the person credit. but an sm artist not crediting a black artist? whats new, am i right?

A whole ass 90 secs of rap and you want to make an issue out of 7 words. You do you I guess.

There are countless phrases used again and again in songs, both English and Korean. But I guess it's not an issue unless it's someone you anti.

You're so obvious.

A 90 second rap and op is trigger by 7 words

and acting like she didn't write the rest of the song

well considering how this thread is embarassing, i understand why OP was so ashame to do it on the main forum and prefer to hide in the anon

People did care when this was released. It was a whole topic on Twitter and on allkpop. No one but Aespa fans take Giselle seriously as a rapper lmao.

Quote from Baked Saffron Rabbit (239)

A whole ass 90 secs of rap and you want to make an issue out of 7 words. You do you I guess.

There are countless phrases used again and again in songs, both English and Korean. But I guess it's not an issue unless it's someone you anti.

You're so obvious.

A 90 second rap and she still couldn't write it all by herself. Needed to use someone else's bar and I wouldn't even be annoyed if mys didnt keep saying how its self written like really? Self written and the best bar is stolen? I'm sorry not stolen but she made a *stylistic choice* and used it without giving credit.

Quote from Stewed Mustard & Thyme Yak (98)

A 90 second rap and op is trigger by 7 words

and acting like she didn't write the rest of the song

well considering how this thread is embarassing, i understand why OP was so ashame to do it on the main forum and prefer to hide in the anon

It's in anon bc I dont want to deal with notifications from giselle stans defending her like usual. At this point she could shoot someone and you guys would defend her.

you are literally searching for an excuse to drag her

this has been covered already, get a grip and move on

This is literally common in rap just like sampling and 7 words does not change the fact Korean and Japanese parts are written by her.

Quote from OP

It's in anon bc I dont want to deal with notifications from giselle stans defending her like usual. At this point she could shoot someone and you guys would defend her.

You're literally trying discredit her for 7 words in a 90 sec rap how delusional can you be? Taylor Swift was called out from using haters gonna hate and players gonna play line in shake it off does that suddenly take away from the fact she's a writer? This horse has been beaten to death you making this dumb ass thread will prove nothing aespa and giselle are still famous and giselle is stll an amazing female idol rapper and living rent free in bitter houxs like you minds.

Lol. Boy oh boy, how some people can be embarassing in their petty hatreds  

OPO, get a life, grow some spine or go outside and touch some grass, hating will shorten your lifespan

Quote from Cooked Cocoa & Mushroom Venison (262)

Lol. Boy oh boy, how some people can be embarassing in their petty hatreds  

OPO, get a life, grow some spine or go outside and touch some grass, hating will shorten your lifespan

LITERALLY aespa has been inactive since December and hating ass antis STILL talk shit about them if that's not pressed idk what is imagine hating a group so much you bring up a incident that was discussed heavily almost 2 years ago , aespa antis number 1 fans wbk.

Did she give credit at least? She really should tbh

This has been covered already. MYs and SM stans think she’s a good rapper but I don’t think she is especially compared to other popular female rappers. Her rapping in Savage was annoying and way too high pitched. I don’t know why SM made her rap in such a high pitched tone.

Quote from Pickled Mint & Orange Bear (855)

This is literally common in rap just like sampling and 7 words does not change the fact Korean and Japanese parts are written by her.

You're literally trying discredit her for 7 words in a 90 sec rap how delusional can you be? Taylor Swift was called out from using haters gonna hate and players gonna play line in shake it off does that suddenly take away from the fact she's a writer? This horse has been beaten to death you making this dumb ass thread will prove nothing aespa and giselle are still famous and giselle is stll an amazing female idol rapper and living rent free in bitter houxs like you minds.

I don't think she is a good rapper compared to her peers. If you're saying in SM I would agree she's pretty good but the bar is so low and Karina's better IMO.

Quote from OP

It's in anon bc I dont want to deal with notifications from giselle stans defending her like usual. At this point she could shoot someone and you guys would defend her.

Don't think she has a lot of stans. There's only that one particular Giselle and aespa stan that is always hyping her up.

Sm stans will defend plagiarism as not a big deal until it's not their favs being accused of it. Then suddenly it's open season for them to drag other idols and become the very people they were defending their idols against.

Looks like someone really hates Giselle or Aespa, or both.

Also, JYP stans coming for Aespa and other SM artists is kind of a bad joke, seeing how JYP has been plagiarizing left and right all the time.

Make a decision, either be ok with all 'plagiarism' stuff and see it what it is, something that happens in all fields and all companies use 'inspiration', or condemn all 'plagiarism' by all companies even when it's done by your own bias' company.

But bashing it if one company does it while defending it when it's about your own biases, double standards like that is just hypocrisy.

Quote from Pickled Mint & Orange Bear (855)

This is literally common in rap just like sampling and 7 words does not change the fact Korean and Japanese parts are written by her.

You're literally trying discredit her for 7 words in a 90 sec rap how delusional can you be? Taylor Swift was called out from using haters gonna hate and players gonna play line in shake it off does that suddenly take away from the fact she's a writer? This horse has been beaten to death you making this dumb ass thread will prove nothing aespa and giselle are still famous and giselle is stll an amazing female idol rapper and living rent free in bitter houxs like you minds.

lol what r u so mad for?

she couldnt even write a 90 second rap all by herself and she blatantly copies a bar and tries to pass it off as self written. thats embarassing

taylor swift's haters gonna hate line isnt even plagarism bc it was a common phrase. who the hell is using the word chalice? she could have atleast credited her or something but she didnt.

also giselle isnt even a good rapper. the sm female rapper bar is so low and even then karina is better