karina rapping > giselle rapping

am i the only one who thinks karina's rapping is way better than giselle's. i sometimes like giselle's but its honestly hit or miss whereas karina has never missed. i feel like whenever i say this, other mys take it as a personal attack towards giselle because they like to act like she's the best rapper but i just think karina is better.

ok Karina gets better verses because she's more popular and has more center time.

Giselle is by default the best rapper she has the flow and delivery and she raps because she has the passion not because made her.

You can like Karina better but to say she's the best when she's never picked up a pen to write her own rap or even has a passion for it is silly.

just because an idol writes or is "passionate" doesnt make them automatically good. i find all of giselle's written raps mediocre and haven't found anything she's rapped mindblowing (just typical idol rapping) whereas karina's flows and delivery are addicting and in my opinion better.

as far as talent goes, any other aespa member >>>>> giselle

this is like comparing the heights of two hobbits

The tea is neither can rap

Quote from OP

just because an idol writes or is "passionate" doesnt make them automatically good.

agree

I actually liked Karina's rapping in Savage better than Giselle's.

Karina had a more exciting flow and rhythm and tone to her rap parts, while Giselle's line at 1:50 where she has to volume it up sounds off for some reason.

Giselle's rapping in English might be better, but in Korean I find Karina's a bit better.

As someone that loves all types of rap music, Giselle is the better rapper but Karina is a good rapper too.

Quote from Deep-Fried Red Whine Bear (211)

agree

thank you. giselle stans think just because giselle writes and listens to hiphop, that automatically means she's a good rapper. anyone can write and theres nothing giselle has written that has been impressive lyrically and anyone can listen to hiphop. both her and karina are just mediocre rappers so u can only judge them on personal taste and karina's flow and delivery just appeals to me more.

i would've disagreed if it wasn't for dreams come true. karina ate that weenie beenie rap

Quote from Brined Pasta & Pork (884)

ok Karina gets better verses because she's more popular and has more center time.

Giselle is by default the best rapper she has the flow and delivery and she raps because she has the passion not because made her.

You can like Karina better but to say she's the best when she's never picked up a pen to write her own rap or even has a passion for it is silly.

how can you be so sure of your words when karina says otherwise? also being passionate - it's just about something you enjoy, but the outsider can still be better.

FHNmzvyWUAYFuxK.png

Giselle is clearly better at rapping. Karina’s rapping reminds me of irene

both cant rap lol

I loved all of karina's rap verses. I think i just like her style of rapping better.

I like both but Karina's voice for me is better in everything it sounds more unique

Giselle sounds better as singer specially in her predebut time

Karina has a good vocal tone. I'd say best in aespa

and that is not that good

cos both sucks!

All sm female rappers and some male sucks