They're both good vocalist but Ningning is better, she's effortless and her technique is superior
lmao this has got to be the same user making all these latest anon threads. lol the hate is evident
agree.
Things to point out:
Lily is singing on a live, she probably hadn't done prep work for live singing on a stream. Lily prepping is extra credit
NingNing on the other hand is on a TV series with a budget. If she hadn't prepped that's just downright negligent.
Lily actually doesn't manage her breath well and as a result cannot support the sustains on the song.
Ningning does that flawlessly.
Lily's audio is totally exposed and direct through a camera.
Ningning has a whole sound system and backing track to support and cover for her mistakes.
My point: this is quite inconclusive; we are comparing apples to oranges in terms of presentation of this song.
It isn't unpopular that ningx2 is a better singer technique-wise
Display MoreThings to point out:
Lily is singing on a live, she probably hadn't done prep work for live singing on a stream. Lily prepping is extra credit
NingNing on the other hand is on a TV series with a budget. If she hadn't prepped that's just downright negligent.
Lily actually doesn't manage her breath well and as a result cannot support the sustains on the song.
Ningning does that flawlessly.
Lily's audio is totally exposed and direct through a camera.
Ningning has a whole sound system and backing track to support and cover for her mistakes.
My point: this is quite inconclusive; we are comparing apples to oranges in terms of presentation of this song.
Clips of young Ning Ning singing in her bedroom on live still clearing Lilly.
lol what
Lily has a very developed sense of support, she's better than pretty much all 4th gen singers other than NingNing. Rose isn't anywhere near that level.
Lily is much better than people here give her credit for, this is some completely raw singing she's showing. SM hasn't let any of their girls show that. Still NingNing has better technique but the gap isn't huge. And Lily is better than Winter for sure.
lol what
Lily has a very developed sense of support, she's better than pretty much all 4th gen singers other than NingNing. Rose isn't anywhere near that level.
Lily is much better than people here give her credit for, this is some completely raw singing she's showing. SM hasn't let any of their girls show that. Still NingNing has better technique but the gap isn't huge. And Lily is better than Winter for sure.
Lily is definitely a better vocalist but idk why when she sings something about her voice reminds me of rose if BP.
this is some completely raw singing she's showing. SM hasn't let any of their girls show that.
This videos are there if you really wanted to watch them
Ningning is better she sings with such ease, Lily struggles and forces
This videos are there if you really wanted to watch them
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.Ningning is better she sings with such ease, Lily struggles and forces
I already said NingNing is better, but this is also a much softer approach (mixed or head voice) than Lily, who usually goes straight for the belt, that's why it sounds like she isn't trying as hard. The gap isn't as big as people here claim, people just like to shit on JYP vocalists. I've seen people saying all Aespa girls are better than Lily which is....lol. But yeah NN is a stronger technical vocalist, strongest in 4th gen so far.
Agree.
I think they're kind of on par with each other, but they have very different vocal colours.
Ningning sounds like a Disney Princess with her sweet clear and pretty voice.
Lily suits more sultry or soul songs.
Also, I've been playing this on repeat. It's so hauntingly beautiful.
The freaking lie. She has been singing live since forever. There are plenty Clips of her singing on radio show if you bother to search on youtube.
Also, you don't have to imagine. The op video have them singing the same song.
Here, this is when she really young.
Here live acapella.
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!
