Is Giselle really a better singer than Rose?

Was from the main thread. True or false? And why?

She usually relies on backing tracks and strains a lot, so I'd say Rose is better.

yes

what lol

no

Rosé is better. The person that replied that was just raging over Rosé like the fake coaches

yes she is

in reality the average person can sing better than rose

The only group that sings worse than Blackpink is Twice. So probably yes.

Rose is the standard? Anyone is better than her.

No, Giselle can't support to bb4, Rosé can. Rosé is the better vocalist.

sm is a genius on using backtracks always on AESPA, you will actually hear her(Giselle) sing live....NEVER.

Rosé sang live on many, many programs. She is always singing and playing the piano or other instruments. She is the real deal.

Well it's not hard to be a better singer than Rosé

Quote from Army Validation (288)

The only group that sings worse than Blackpink is Twice. So probably yes.

Lol nah Jihyo and Nayeon >>>>>>>>>>>

ROse

As a non fan of both group, Ningning, Karina & Jennie has nicer vocals than Rose. While giselle should stay in sm basement for at least 2 more years.

Quote from Northern Validation (959)

No, Giselle can't support to bb4, Rosé can. Rosé is the better vocalist.

Keep the delusion in your head people, this is the only true here