Lim Young Woong vs Txt: Who will have a more successful comeback?

    Both are coming back in May. On Ktown4u, Txt has 30,000 orders(concept photos not released yet), Lim Young Woong has 100,000 orders. Digitals, physicals, who will be more successful?

  • Moderator

    Approved the thread.

    digitals: Lim Youngwoong obviously

    physicals: most likely TXT, doesn't LYW depend on his very hardcore Korean fandom? in that case I don't expect his preorders to keep growing at this rate

    Quote from OP

    They were close to entering Melon 100 Daily last time. I think their digitals are improving quick.

    How impressive. :pepe-popcorn:

    Is this a TXT set-up? Clearly it will be LYW. Kcharts LYW by far (he will have multiple songs in top 10 easy and probably at least one in top 5) - not even close competition. Physicals ... LYW's sales are predicted to be massive - he has large, older (and thus with more money to spend) and dedicated fanbase in Korea. His actual preorders will be much higher than the 100k on ktown4u because Koreans don't generally use ktown4u.


    The only metric TXT will have the upper hand (by far) will be international streaming.

    Quote from Pressure-Cooked Salted Pigeon (209)

    digitals: Lim Youngwoong obviously

    physicals: most likely TXT, doesn't LYW depend on his very hardcore Korean fandom? in that case I don't expect his preorders to keep growing at this rate

    Those preorders are just ktown4u preorders though. As you said, his fans are mostly Koreans and most of them won't be using ktown4u to order.

    Depends on which metric you are talking about

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!

Register Yourself Login