Finished the 2nd season recently and enjoyed it which I wouldn't have expected when I watched the first episode of the series. I really enjoy the adventure treasure hunt parts of the shows and the antagonists but wish they would cut down on the romantic plotline. It kills the mood and throws off the show for me and frankly don't care about either couples. JJ and Pope are probably my favorites of the main casts and most likely wouldn't watch without them but I think they're all pretty much likable.
Warning for actual spoilers below
I kind of wish they would just kill Sarah's dad already and that they didn't bring back John B's dad as a plot twist. I just think it's stupid to bring back John B's dad and I'm not really vibing with it. And a side note, the show does too many fake out deaths How many did we even have this season?
Also if they're going the magic route with the treasure, I definitely think John B's fabric was from the cross