Does a loud backtrack count as live singing?

I think it doesn't.

Discuss.

I guess this is about Blackpink? I hate the loud backtrack they use. Especially when their vocals aren't stable it sounds like the sound is cutting in and out.

Don't be shy, name the group. Maybe then you'll get some of that attention you crave so bad. For now tho hate to break it to you but you flopped

It’s technically still live but it shows a big lack of confidence in their abilities

It's still live, just less impressive when you can hardly hear the real live voices above the loud soundtrack.

lol all kpop groups do that, agree they are all embarrassing then

It’s technically still live but don’t see much point with it if you can’t hear them anyways. Just feels like they’re trying to score brownie points but don’t have the confidence to actually sing live

still better than full lipsync . the bar is low nowadays

Tell that to most K-pop groups

Does this includes your faves?

I'm Army.

BP did well despite their limitations though.

Quote from Friendly Anons Neighbor (562)

Does this includes your faves?

no, tbh

Technically it is singing: It is singing that cannot be heard.

Quote from Aegyo Supporter (136)

lol all kpop groups do that, agree they are all embarrassing then

Quote from Friendly Anons Neighbor (660)

the bar is low nowadays

Quote from Friendly Anons Neighbor (562)

Tell that to most K-pop groups

Unfortunately every kpop group uses loud backtrack

If the backtrack is louder than their voices then no

no if back track is louder than actual voices ie bp, aespa

In televised events, microphones in general ain't louder than stereos, so that is why backtrack sound louder in every music shows. But in live when you go to an x act concert, you do hear the microphone more