Posts by 8y3heus

Quote from Typhonsentra

It really is shocking to go to the Chart tracking Twitter pages and seeing no updates on their streaming performance. One song had one day on the Global 200 and zero in the US specifically and it only charted in the top 40 in Singapore. These are depressingly bad results for an established group, and somehow their monthly followers are also declining despite being in the middle of a comeback.

Honestly clear outside of the hardcore fanbase, Twice really isn't consumed by many people in any country except maybe still Japan.

Definitely selling a bit more than Lisa, so probably around the 1m mark.

Quote from Aeicy

that looks like a twice anti account are those real stats?

Anti account or not, they are real. The song was fully out of every daily chart on day 2.

Quote from chartslover

yup, and its doing terrible on spotify because they split the streams between the eng ver and the kr one

the fans are streaming the kr one but the label is putting the eng one in playlist, so the streams are essentially split in two

I feel like we dont talk enough about how badly jype artists are managed and how bad they're marketing strategies are...

they can rely on big fandoms to sell albums but the marketing is terrible, all the other big companies are miles ahead of jyp on this point, feels like they dont know what theyre doing at all

Display More

Combined, the streams were less than TTT and MS though, so that's saying something as well.

The good news is, I would assume billboard combines the English and Korean versions for its chart, since they combine remix and main versions. So if fans bulk buy the downloads enough, they might make the bubbling under again.

When JYP chooses the title tracks for his groups, it feels like he's just reaching in the garbage bin of other producers and hoping what he pulls out is hidden treasure.

I think it was just more pronounced this comeback because it literally only lasted 1 day in the daily chart on Melon. There may have been some hyperbole with the flops of the last several years, but this one was shocking.

Cross Roads or One Way I bet.

Looking for Twice's 2.5m+ selling album, any relevant hit songs in the past several years, I can't seem to find any. Yeah I don't think they can hold a candle to BP

Quote from SooYoung

i'm talking about the time when blackpink released the album '-'

3 years ago? Ah ok

Quote from SooYoung

it's not a new narratives, this narratives is use against all the top best selling GG

last time it was Aespa who was victim of this narrative too

people just use it because they are mad that GG can sell well

and twice is just the new victim because their latest album sales finally reach the sales of Aespa and Blackpink so they were doom to face this narrative

They reached the sales of Aespa, but the gap between 1.7m and 2.65m is almost a million lol.

Quote from chartslover

Debuted at 83 and is currently 95

Second Day on the daily chart is out. That is shocking. I don't recall even Scientist falling out that fast.

I was wondering why it stopped at 69, but the tweet was made after Twice crawled their way to the 70th biggest day, with the release of this album.

The streams of the actual music in international markets has been poor this comeback as well.
Good for the fans for increasing their album buying efforts though because that has clearly paid off if the HDD prediction holds up.

The better the albums sell, the worse their music does.

Anyone know Set Me Free's 24 hour unique listeners?
Seems to already be out of Melon real time.

The more the albums sell, the worse the music does. Seems to be the trend the last few years for Twice.

Aespa?

Not that shocking that BP is about 5 times as popular as Twice globally. Not shocking that BTS is in first either.