If Girls was released in October rather than July would it have smashed?

According to MYs 'Girls' underperformance is due to it being released during the summer and use Savage being released in October as an example.

Do you agree?

Savage only did well at the start because of next level, not because of when it came out

if my grandma had wheels she would have been a bike

No it would’ve flopped even more because Aespa is declining