So you LOWKEY admit Aespa is THAT good even you can't believe it
Yep, a good little progress I guess
too-good-to-be-true doesnt mean they are THAT good tho. It means good for their live vocal. that why I have to wait a little longer for more of their live. but still, they are second best live vocal rookie
the fact that you need 1 unstable vocal doesn't mean it's live
you don't need to be a bad vocalist to be live
omg you're embarassing
yes, I am wrong here
what I mean is performance with dance
it is different with ballad performance
the first one is live
clearly you can't even differenciate live vocals and not live vocals
you should stop acting like you know anything about vocal, you're becoming embarassing af
this clip is published on aespa official youtube, long after she sang that song, obviously not a Live Show
I dont care if she really is singing there. It has to be singing Live at Live show. Plus, you dont know what kind of edit the company did to the clip
Display MoreHmmm, maybe you're right, I judge them too hard, because in Black Mamba promotion I never even once hear their Live vocal when performing.
And their Live vocal from other source is hard to find too.
The judgement is still in my head tho. Lol.
Even when they sing ballad song, without dance at all, they sound too-good-to-be-true. Again, because I dont have enough proof, I still think that is pre-recorded
Maybe I need to wait a little longer. I hope no heart feeling.
One more thing, I put them second on my list tho.
I never said their vocal is bad
I have more receipts if you need them
I'm just sick and tired of people like you that can't comprehend how talented aespa really are because you're used to terrible live singing. How prejudged and closed minded are you, yet you keep getting proven wrong, it's embarrassing now
Hmmm, maybe you're right, I judge them too hard, because in Black Mamba promotion I never even once hear their Live vocal when performing.
And their Live vocal from other source is hard to find too.
The judgement is still in my head tho. Lol.
Even when they sing ballad song, without dance at all, they sound too-good-to-be-true. Again, because I dont have enough proof, I still think that is pre-recorded
Maybe I need to wait a little longer. I hope no heart feeling.
Display MoreLMAOOOOOOOOO OP using a video of Ningning when she was 12yo without any vocal lessons to compare to recent videos of the other girls with years of vocal training x))))
and you're trying to say you didn't try to set her up , Big jokes -_-
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
do you need more receipt or you'll once again trying to make a third Thread to criticize Aespa vocals -_-
that's why I ask for better Live vocal of ningning
the first video is definitely not Live
If I put your second video in this post, it will be unfair because all other main vocal has at least 1 minute clip
the third is basically the same clips I use right? why you debate using my material.
Display MoreErmmm you do know radios aren't live as well, majority are heavily auto-tuned also literally the video I posted yesterday was a LIVE video, I don't know why you're still refusing to believe it, and then the videos posted by people in the same chat that again is clearly live but you refuse to believe
Here to jog your memory
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
I don't know why you're saying it shouldn't be included because they're having fun when they're harmonising, and hitting notes so carelessly. Who cares if it's not being taken seriously, if anything it backs up the fact they are vocally the best if they're hitting notes while having fun, walking everywhere, who else has done this please
"Live" from music show is debatable, that's why I don't use it as proof that they can sing Live
Here is the catch with music show:
1. If you only hear 1 vocal, that is the background music or pre-recorded, NOT Live
2. If you hear 2 vocal and both are clear, that is backsound music and pre-prerecorded
3. If you hear 2 vocal and 1 vocal is more unstable sounds worse than the other, that is Live
People tend to believe that their idol pre-recorded as Live, but not wanting to seek the truth
The "Going Home Live" is to showcase their entertainment skill, not vocal skill. Well, in fact every "Going Home Live" idols can hit their song well, you know why? because it is their song. Lol.
I had higher expectations for Purple Kiss in terms of vocal skills but they still are a little bit above the average of kpop GGs nowadays
Yeah me too. Many people were hyping them so my expectation is kinda higher than what they can give. Maybe it's because of the "they are from xxx so they must be good at singing" thing
I didn't mean to make ningning look bad. I just don't find any good Live vocal for her, and for aespa also. There is little to none of their Live vocal as of right now, I mean REALLY hard to find them, escpecially singing their own song Live
If you have better Live vocal of them, do attach here
I want to update the post
But only radio or vlive clip, where we can validate their "Live"ness
OH MY GOD A NEWBIE APPEARED HERE, I guess someone's alt acting up
Then show this newbie a solid evidence of their Live vocal. Don't rant here.
I need real Live vocal
it show that even when they are just joking around their vocals are flawless
so on stage it can only be even more perfect
I smell biased speculation here
:-D
just leaving this Here for people who still try to discredit Aespa vocals
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Also in this video, they are just having fun. I won't use this video as the Live vocal evidence to show other people if I were you. This shows nothing about their Live vocal skill.
No, no ones debating anymore. Even on YouTube everyone's finally admitting it. They've sang different songs on radio, but their behind the scene of the forever performance, theres parts where they're literally sining random songs with their WORKING microphone that's clearly on, that people choose to ignore and now they have finally released a focus cam from the same distance where you can clearly here the difference. And this isn't the edited performance from the show, read it clearer please, this is a focus cam, this is raw, hence why I said a minute ago they couldn't have edited afterwards. Side focus cams you always here pre recordings or live, also listen with earphones, you can clearly hear the live version and if you still think it's pre recorded then you clearly just having a hard time accepting the truth
Everyone on youtube will say their fave sing Live, even though it is 100% backsound music. Lol.
Yes this cam is raw, but they use pre-recorded. Do they sound like Live singing for you?
Here check their real Live:
4th Gen Girl Group Live Vocal (Aespa, Purple Kiss, Secret Number, Stayc, Weeekly)/
It is as you said, they sing random song. But you CAN validate that this is Live. Rather than showing their Live from music show, radio or vlive Live is a more validate proof that your idol can sing Live
Oh wow you’re still trying
You can literally hear the difference of pre recording and live and this isn’t recorded special like the performance video or a music show stage, these are literally side focused recording, you may need to clean Your ears if you can’t hear the difference, there’s no faking that, as hard as you try to make it out
See? performance from music show is not clear enough. There will be people debating whether it is "Live" or not
That's why I ask for their "Live" from radio or vlive, where their vocal is more clear
Then we can give more precise score
After School is the best song from 4th gen gg debuted from 2019-2021
Love Bomb from fromis_9 is the best song from all 4th gen gg. Second one would be After School
Display MoreThey have finally posted a full and individual focus cam (if you really want to go into detail) in forever performance, I'm so tired of people claiming the girls don't sing live because they're that good and stable
This is what pre recorded sounds like in focus cams
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
This is what Live Sounds like in focus cams
Big difference! The girls have already sang live, they are just that good
External Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Your example "Live Sounds" sounds 90% pre-recorded
Could you give their "Live Sounds" from radio or vlive?
That's where idols usually sing live
Vocal
This is undeniable. She the best vocalist of 4th gen gg. If she is not at least in your top 3 vocalist list, you have to do more research or maybe you are too biased
Dance
You can see her dance cover in youtube and tiktok. She can carry smooth move, sharp move, powerful move, or any kind of move. Her moves are fluent and precise
Rap
This is hard to see because weeekly song doesn't focus on rap, but you can hear in live version that her rap is good. Checkout her cover of 'New Rules' on 11.55, her fast-speak is so good
For now, no one in 4th gen girl group come close to her for the ACE title.
Even when compared to 3th gen girl group, I doubt that there is anyone can compete with her
The difference is, I provide their live material
Hoping that voters would listen to their live vocal, and not judging them just by their company, sister's group, popularity, concept, and what other people say
Entirely by live vocal
But, well, seems like most voters didn't even bother to see the videos
Can't help with it tho
Nonetheless, we know have mini compilation of their live vocal here
