Posts by dontwannacry04
-
-
Also please tell me the tags worked...
-
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
No wonder why they are on private for other people lol
I wonder if they will change the date or something...?
-
-
SAY THE NAME
WELCOME TO THE DIAMOND RESIDENCE
[CARATS CODE OF CONDUCT]
The main virtue of being a Carat is to not engage in foolish fan wars.
We do not degrade or diminish other groups to one up them.
Be nice to everyone, and stay focused on Seventeen!
Before the revamp, we had a Diamond Residence (taglist) thread that we occasionally used as a chatroom. Unfortunately, we lost a very active and lively thread, a place for Caratโs to chat.
Hence, this place was created as an official comfort place for everyone to share their thoughts, opinions, and things they find online. Non-fans are also welcomed as long as they stay respectful.
Please feel free to utilize this thread as you wish. Letโs revive our โchatroomโ!
-
-
In terms of fandom power, touring, and physicals Seventeen and NCT have a edge over them, but when it comes to digitals and general public recognition, RV and MMM will have a edge over those two (though I wouldnโt say Svt is completely unknown in Korea).
Personally I feel like the list from these four would go a bit like this;
Seventeen > RV = MMM
(I am not sure how we can rank NCT since they are a project, and donโt comeback as frequently due to the dynamic of their concept.)
-
-
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
-
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
-
AzuraLaz can you get the taglist for me?
-
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
King thingz!
Their average GoSe viewers is like 1M-2M.
Literally GoSe is THE best variety show by an idol group out there.
-
-
I will just leave this here since I mentioned Cravity in the OP...
External Content twitter.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.This is so cute!
-
Display More
First off on the 'more streams' horseshit...yeah when a fandom is looping songs playlist at 4am in the morning every night for years straight I kind of expect that...but with all those streams above groups like BP, Twice, etc lets count Seventeens and NCT digital certs.....so if I grab my calculator out I can see...yep that's 0 DL certs for either and, oh again, 0 streaming certs for either group....yeah kind of expected those 'low quality' streams to be filtered out.
500k UL's? Huh? Seventeens last song peaked at 103k UL's on Melon and the 2nd day of release dropped out of the top 100 and it's currently sitting at 605 on Melon after what? 3 months....bro that's 15.9k listeners and these guys have 197k followers on Melon...
Nearly 200k fans on Melon that's about 8% of their fans still listening and the song is still pretty new....Checking em out on d1 is one thing but talking about in weeks dropping below 20k listeners when you're selling 1.2m or w/e and you gonna with a straight face tell me their fans care about their music....lol. Groups like NCT fair just a poorly.
The bottom line is, if their fans liked their music they would listen to it but with the fact that they aren't charting well on any chart in Korea, chart for like 3 weeks in Japan, have pretty low YT views and even worse Spotify streams...these groups sell like 3-5 million albums a year yet no one is playing their songs....
Fans lie, numbers don't.
So youโre just gonna ignore Heng:Garae? It was also released in 2020. Charted very well as well, it hit #1 and spent 330+ hours in top 10 MelOn before reform. After reform it didnโt fall off the charts instead it went up from the 20s and peaked at #16 not to mention how it stayed in the rank 20s and 30s for nearly a month after the reform. On Genie they have 840k ULs as well, and on Gaon 111M+ digital points. You canโt say no one is listening to their music, that is a stretch. 2.2B+ streams on MelOn, 1.2B+ streams on Gaon (based on last yearโs July update), 1.2B+ streams on Spotify doesnโt seem like no one is listening to them. Also, you need to realize how MelOn is only 1 out numerous streaming sites in Korea.
76B47FB1-78DC-4955-948F-99D28A0B27B5.jpeg
I am in no way saying they are a digimon, but they definitely do well for a fan driven group. Your question can also be reversed as well. Why canโt acts that chart high on MelOn even hit 500k-1M physical sales if they have so many people listening to them? The only act that comes to my mind that consistently sells millions and has out of the world charting every comeback is only BTS.
Literally I saw the same thread just couple days ago, yโall are getting uncreative.
-
-
If it becomes vlive/weverse content..I can imagine it will be like the pledis youtube channel the ring merch incidents all over again..carats would be livid.
Carats will be furious, the outrage will be scary because it will be coming from both Carats and Cubics.
-
If they turn it into Vlive/Weverse exclusive, I am gonna be so mad. I hope that idea is nothing near reality.
-
I think we shouldn't divide it and shouldn't put it in the Spoiler.
Yeah I am thinking the same thing, tysmm
-
