no but really, each gen needs at least 7 years to solidify, end of 2nd gen and beginning of 3rd was around 2012/13 so that means it was at least 2020 before you could claim a new gen. Anything after aespa should only be considered 4th gen. SKZ and BP who many consider the epitome of 3rd gen debuted less than 2 years from each other - concept wise they also share more in common with 3rd gen than with current groups today
I think 4th gen got the short end because BTS was so everywhere/all the time that the market was kind of saturated and people didn't want more BGs.
I do think SKZ has an argument for top 10 though. Monster fanbase. The only con would be that they don't really have that monster song everyone knows.
Agreed. BTS cast too large a shadow over BGs, they dominated both the 3rd gen AND the 4th gen eras while 3rd gen GGs eventually had to bow down to 4th gen GGs like Ive, Aespa, Idle, LSRFM, and NJ.
Imagine if she had chosen SM and debuted as the maknae of Aespa in 2020. Two of the funniest most charming idols in the business in one group with Karina and Minji.
thebadguy Would you be stanning Aespa if Minji was their 5th member or would you still be stanning that sociopath MHJ
I've hypothesized that 4th gen peaked with Supernova and that we will see something else take over Korean music scene over the next year. Could be 5th gen which will soon come online (Izna, Teddy's NGG, or SM's NGG). Or it could be something different like band music, trot, or this trot idol hybrid concept.
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
When Sakura cried 10000x harder for Chaeyeon than she did for herself.
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Display More
ULs are down to 250k now, i dont think these roof hits really mean much.
ULs overall are just terrible for summer months. They're worse than the past winter.
Literally 35 hours is all you ungrateful fools have.
Remember that NJ's most precious record, Ditto's 14 weeks at #1 on Melon, is being challenged by Aespa's Supernova.
I did the math after I read that Supernova just hit 11 weeks as of Aug 4.
So if Supernova keeps going...
Aug 11 = 12 weeks
Aug 18 = 13 weeks
Aug 25 = 14 weeks
Sept 1 = 15 weeks
So if nothing happens, this means that Ditto's 14 weeks at #1 record will fall when Sept 1 charts are released (Sunday).
However, there is onebrave group of souls that could stand in the way.
One group that has been the victim of the worst hate train ever seen in Kpop, which has been exacerbated and promoted by the very sociopath that some of y'all Tokkis worship.
Bloodied and battered but never defeated, this group is your one chance at redemption and to keep from losing that precious record.
But this is a tall order to ask of anyone. 1.3 million cumulative ULs will probably be needed in those 35 hours from Aug 30 to Aug 31 for LSRFM's single. Not even IU or BTS could do this. But if K Tokkis do the right thing, shake off that Stockholm Syndrome voodoo magic that she has weaved over your gullible asses, and band together with K Fearnuts against the machinations of the Narcissistic Sociopath, perhaps a miracle can happen.
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
I never felt it was about having another Suzy. When companies try to limit their workers like this, it's so the brad remains bigger than the individuals. The individuals become more reliant on the brand for the image, limiting their individual influence outside of the group, which gives the company more control. The company can then exert more power over the idol in the form of money, music, and marketing. The longer an idol stays with the company, the more power the company has over the idol. It's whySM flopped with SNSD during contract negotiations.
You see this with other big entertainment companies like WWE in the past. There's a delicate balance for the company: you want the idols to be more reliant on you, but you also want them to be actually popular to draw fans. If you succeed, you have a Taeyeon situation, and if you fail, you a Blackpink situation.
Of course, idols can always just take their chances and succeed on their own. Something tells me, if Twice was really at one point the NGG (and it wasn't just media play), they should all be popular enough to succeed without JYPE, if they want. Maybe some even surpassing Suzy too.
Great job of summarizing the complicated landscape of idol/label relations. They're not always enemies/antagonists and not always partners/BFFs, it's a balancing act like you say.
I sometimes get why Twice gets dragged on this forum.. some of y'all onces really are delulu.. like comparing Suzy to.. Jihyo??! Put some respect on Suzy's name
Is she dissing NJ? We all know LSRFM and Itzy are the best dancers/performers in 4th gen, Aespa and Ive are well regarded for their vocals. Idle has songwriting creds and of course Soyeon rap writing creds.
But NJ literally has NOTHING to hang their hats on except music that MHJ stole for them from Pink Pantheress and that 80s band, and concepts that were stolen from Speed and that Mexican GG. They're average dancers, mediocre vocalists, with zero personality. Except mah girl Minji of course
The shittiest fans on Twitter are all Blinks. This person is just jokingly mocking her for doing something kind of ridiculous. You're making something out of nothing.
Oh i wasnt talking about the Twitter account that posted this. I was talking about Mys and SM stans on TW in general. The most toxic easily, 10x more than Blinks, Tokkis, or Dives.
Karina deserves the world. She deserves the most loyal, most balanced, the most normal fans in Kpop.
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Just look at this gem. Literal It Girl, yet she's cursed with the most disgusting fanbase on Twitter tbh.
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.
Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.