i saw that back in 2020, 2019, 2018 or 2017
idk which year
Posts by NineMusesMinha
-
-
their company shouldve sue for defamation and whatever else its call but bruh
-
Yeah it's not like it.
Hwayoung never said she was bullied. She even came out stating that it was a petty argument but not bullying. But she saw how the scandal was giving her more favorable attention so she rode the wave shortly after and never tried to settle things down anymore. The one time she tried to change her story to say she was bullied, that's when ex-staff came out with proof that it was her and her sister who was bullying the newest T-ara member, Areum.
In this case, Hyunjoo and her brother are outright stating she was bullied by APRIL + Somin.
so netizens just blindly follow hwayoung even though she said she was never bullied. okay makes sense.
-
the court of public opinion > an actual court...
and cheaper...
IM CONFUSED WHAT THIS MEANS
-
Don't know the 100% full details of the case, but this sounds so much like the T-ARA case.
It took T-ARA 4 years and some mistakes of Hwayoung and her sister, in order for those dense, gullible netizens (and ifans :rolleyes1: ) to realize that what they blindly tagged a 'bullying' case, was nothing but a work conflict and difference of opinion, where 1 colleague couldn't (or wouldn't) keep up with the others.
can we use a lying detector where hyunjoo and the members gather up please cause like, that's how we know who's lying...
-
All them dumbass statements + wrong dates are exactly why people are taking Hyunjoo’s side
Did they bully her? IMO, no. They just had justifiable conflict. They were most likely fed up with her at times since basically she was their coworker. I feel as if she were put into any other group with her work ethic she’d get the exact same treatment.
But FUCK. These April members are stupid LOOOOOL.
I just have a question, this isn't like T-ARA right?
-
-
Okay they went that quick?
I mean I guess they're busy but I was legit CONFIDENT my question was gonna be answered. -
so she attack the members years after everything happened
saw that nobody supported her
and decided to apologize
'-'
girl no-
honestly if you're not a fan of nine muses, you don't deserve to have a opinion on this but go ahead.
-
It's a pity anyway. Both parties suffered.
but its no ones fault anyway. i support all the members and thank god i did cuz lee sem posted about her feelings.
ima just put the blame on the producers and maybe jae jae but i heard sera was invited
EXCUSE ME
-
So people make a whole lot of nothing after her initial comments.
explain more on what you mean
-
Bc tbh... If she decided to leave i don't see why she said in a way that the members should stay in touch with her.. we all know and she too how busy kpop idols are and how exhausting their life is so i don't see the problem with losing contact as well, she decided to leave the team...
But this is just if she decided to leave, as we know nothing about it I will still say that she needs to understand that they obviously had reasons to not call her..
i mean i cant not imagine working everyday like she said and wanted to a break or quit
i have a playlist of nine muses performances and there were tons and tons from 2013
and the fact they had 4 comebacks during that year.
-
Why did she decide to quit from the group??
- she either was done with nine muses and wanted to do something else
- she got kicked out/fired
thats all really I have
-
There are 2 translations for the post, please read both so you can have a better understanding.
source for twitter
I already share my feelings on my platforms but I just feel so bad for Lee Sem and what she went through
. I always want her to know we always trust and believe in her like the rest of the members. -
Hey UP10TION
First of all, I want to say I know you guys for more than 4 years and I became a fan after you guys released Destiny.
My questions are
1) What country have you guys not visit and would like to visit
2) Who wants to debut as a solo artist?
3) Do you guys have pets?
4) For Bitto, I love you :)
-
seems like it
why cant we respect each other's culure
i guess i should be offended if a black person is trying to look chinese.
but honestly, i cant even speak for you but i really dont care about this as a asian person.
-
Display More
First i don't stan or hate Treasure i'm talking from an exterior point of view, this thread is only to discuss so if you might get trigger that people might say that your favs aren't doing so well etc.. please leave this thread
we are here to talk so if you are here to quote everybody who doesn't praise your favs and turn this into a mess i don't think you should stay
Let me start :
before Treasure debut everybody was saying how Treasure will be one of the group leading the new generation with TXT, SKZ since they were the only big company BG who debuted in 4th gen
they had a lot of predebut coming out from a survival show, they are from YG a company who always had successfull BG since their debut, they had yearsof build up with yedam being expose as futur member for years before debuting
and their show make a lot of people hype their members skills and visual.
People were talking about how popular they were already in Japan and how they will be in Korea once they debut
they had content on youtube and uploaded a dance video who was well received during predebut
for all these reasons Treasure was always listed as one of the biggest competitor of 4th gen
now flashforward to now
they released 4 title track already , with 3 single album and 1 full album
none of their songs did well in Melon and it's comprehensible considering that it's hard to chart in melon
but none of their song charted in Gaon digital neither, for example even if you watch the charting of other 4th gen BG they all had a song charting in Gaon digital, the boyz, Ateez, enhypen, TXT even a BG like AB6IX who doesn't seem to be as popular than them and came from a much smaller company had every song charted in the gaon digital chart
and when you watch their physicals sales on Gaon even with 4 physicals release, their sales didn't made a big jump
i honestly always thought that they were doing really really well in physicals because a lot of people were saying this and it's true they are doing great
but when you watch their sales they didn't grow a lot at every release, their best selling physicals sold 290K if we doesn't count the kinho version with it
in comparison a BG like The Boyz who don't have the chance to be from a big company is already selling 367K
Ateez is selling 467K
and when you compare with other top agency BG of 4th gen
TXT already sold 700K in preorder
and when you take the example of a BG who debuted later than treasure and had less physicals release like Enhypen who already sold 622K
they seems behind in term of physicals compare to all the others 4th gen
even when talking about buzz among Kpop fans , i see very few fans of treasure in the other kpop forum in US and France
I see a lot more people talking about other 4th gen BG , that they are fan or just casual listener
seems like a lot of Kpop fans don't really take attention o Treasure
and honestly it seems like there was more buzz and talk about treasure duing their predebut than now
even in the koreans community, i see never any hot post about treasure or treasure member now in theqoo or pann etc...
while i used to see a lot during their predebut about mashiro visual
After this exposure of treasure performance, what do you think explain Treasure underwhelming performance in every area compare to other 4th gen BG ?
and what do you think YG should do to improve Treasure overall performance to make them more popular
it hasnt been a year yet. look at UP10TION, they're struggling and they've been in the game for almost 6 years.
-
agreed it is so all over the place and messy 😂 first two seasons were great idk what is happening now
should i stop watching?
ive been stuck on episode 21 for the past 2 months
-
Display MoreExternal Content www.youtube.comContent embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.
if you’re going to attempt cultural appropriation then at least do it right because lord....
is that dreadlocks?
-
After School reunion was basically Bang line up but without some members not attending for various reasons (schedule, scandal etc) without newer members, even them have some people commenting on why Uee wasn't there, they could invite Dolls line up + newer members or at least they could have told the girls like "you know we are gonna reunite with the latest line up", pretending they never existed wasn't smart
everything is HARD
