Chart reform really affected digimons!

Spill.

bugs and genie still kinda....lol

The way BTS is charting 7 songs in melon top 50 is praiseworthy.

And what I like is when BTS wins soty with any song, it proves its potential by passing the test of time.

2020 Dynamite top 20

2019 BWL

2017 Spring Day __ #MyLove

2018 Fake Love on Melon 200

Butter & PTD top 5. I hope Both of their longevity stun us.

SLR, LGO are cherry on top.

SK loves BTS's music.💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

Quote from TheBotter

Well they have 780k fans on Melon. if only 10% of those stream, a low ball number for BG's, it's likely they can chart a song for as long as they like in the top 100, while most other groups are not even close to that fan number, so 10% of their audience would be unlikely to make any meaningful difference to a song's longevity.

yeah sure. if you haven't known melon are dependent on uls for longetivity. streaming alone won't help. nice try.

streaming or mass streaming still works on bugs and genie though.

Quote from BUTTERBOYS

You think all 780k are active and just fans? That 780k includes gp. No song can smash week after week without gp support . 7 million uls for sd are fandriven too? Gallup polls are fandom driven too and bts ranking among 50 plus old people in polls is fan driven too

Fd streaming narrative is going old now to discredit their song's success. From olympic athletes to actors who play BTS songs are their fans. Welcome. Gp are BTS fans in 2021.

But carry on believing what u want to! First chart reform was going to end them and now after chart reform, narrative remains same. Lol

I find it hilarious how often the fandom narrative comes up, I wish people were more creative about their discrediting

aren't they tired already? lol. always writing essays in appreciation threads to change nothing in the end.

Quote from BUTTERBOYS

You think all 780k are active and just fans? That 780k includes gp. No song can smash week after week without gp support . 7 million uls for sd are fandriven too? Gallup polls are fandom driven too and bts ranking among 50 plus old people in polls is fan driven too

Fd streaming narrative is going old now to discredit their song's success. From olympic athletes to actors who play BTS songs are their fans. Welcome. Gp are BTS fans in 2021.

But carry on believing what u want to! First chart reform was going to end them and now after chart reform, narrative remains same. Lol

Quote from TheBotter

None of this changes the fact that only 10% to 15% of BTS fans can keep them charting forever. lifetime UL's will always go up for SD as long as it's in the top 100 since, well new users join Melon each month/year and will doubtless make their way through the top 50 songs since Melon direct's listeners to the 24Hits/formerly real time chart as the primary way of absorbing new music.

I mean it's not like their fans don't make it a public point of interest to specifically stream and mass buy their music. All fandoms do it sure, but most fandoms having 10-15% participation on Melon would be likely 10-20 thousand listeners. Barely enough to scrape top 800.

A real example of fandom mass streaming would be KKB, Spring Day only recently surpassed it to become the #1 most streamed song on melon despite the difference in ULs being 7.2M to 3.9M.

Quote from TheBotter

Well they have 780k fans on Melon. if only 10% of those stream, a low ball number for BG's, it's likely they can chart a song for as long as they like in the top 100, while most other groups are not even close to that fan number, so 10% of their audience would be unlikely to make any meaningful difference to a song's longevity.

Well, BTS have that discovery that turns GP into Army. Not their fault if they have such a diverse discovery which makes GP fall in love with them irrespective of Age, preference. And most importantly Lyrics.

And after "listening & understanding" Spring Day, I wonder which South Korean didn't fall in love with them.

They have 780K followers on melon but Spring Day has 7.2Millions unique listeners on melon. It means 6.42 Millions accounts who don't even follow them listened to Spring Day. That's on when you are the king of GP.

Pressed ppl always find reasons to make themselves happy abt their fav's not having all these achievements .

anyways BTS keeping winning , change kcharts , or billboards charts !!!!

Quote from BUTTERBOYS

Was top in gallup and over 2 billion digital index.

It has 1.7B

Quote from TheBotter

None of this changes the fact that only 10% to 15% of BTS fans can keep them charting forever. lifetime UL's will always go up for SD as long as it's in the top 100 since, well new users join Melon each month/year and will doubtless make their way through the top 50 songs since Melon direct's listeners to the 24Hits/formerly real time chart as the primary way of absorbing new music.

I mean it's not like their fans don't make it a public point of interest to specifically stream and mass buy their music. All fandoms do it sure, but most fandoms having 10-15% participation on Melon would be likely 10-20 thousand listeners. Barely enough to scrape top 800.

So if the same people are mass streaming, then their songs would be in similar spots on Melon or even be swapping. Butter and PTD is like the only case I've seen of this after chart reform for BTS

Quote from TheBotter

Well they have 780k fans on Melon. if only 10% of those stream, a low ball number for BG's, it's likely they can chart a song for as long as they like in the top 100, while most other groups are not even close to that fan number, so 10% of their audience would be unlikely to make any meaningful difference to a song's longevity.

How many of those fans are actively using Melon though? 780k is a high number, but if people stopped using the service or just follow them, then that number doesn't mean much for your argument.