Which SM remake do you prefer? aespa's Forever or Red Velvet's Be Natural

I prefer be natural SM really improved the SES version and it shows.

I prefer rnb and the sultry vibe of Be Natural.

Definitely Be Natural

Be Natural

Be Natural concept is my favorite

Girls' Generation by Girls' Generation

Be natural

Be Natural

Be Natural is on another level

Be Natural all the way here..

Be Natural ofc. I like the choreo so much

Be Natural

Be Natural is a masterpiece. A 2000 song that sounds like a modern retro-inspired song. It's an unfair comparison.

Quote from SooYoung

Be natural

i liked both but forever was just too slow to me too really enjoye it

It's the TY track. Your DP and sig don't lie.

I didn't expect that so few people would prefer Forever, like me LOL

Its such a sweet, calm song.

I find Be Natural(and all of early Velvet songs) to be really boring.

The Luvie in me prefers Forever and I feel alone lol.

I'd say for SM gg as a whole, its Girls' Generation, but between the two given choices I'll go with Be natural. If I will rank RV's catalogue including the remakes, Be Natural would be among the top 5. It's a really good song and I love Wendy and Seulgi's vocals in that song to the exponential level. Red Velvet gave it justice and that song was what cemented their status to me as the 3rd gen gg that qualifies my requirements for a top tier vocal group. It's the song that made me completely love them.