Am I the only one annoyed with MR Removed videos?

If people really want to be 100% sure how a group they're interested in sound live, they should simply check on encores, behind the scenes and radio performances

I'd also recommend Sketchbook, but from what I understand, there's some audio upscaling/tweaking/tuning being done at the show as well, to make it sound just that tad better?

Something I've always wondered, even years ago already: if every music show has the groups perform like 4-5+ times for recording, and they're using and knitting several different clips from multiple performances for 1 video broadcast, while using only 1 audiotrack, either from 1 performance or a separate audio - won't you always have moments where video (lip movements) and audio won't sync up?

Because unless I'm mistaken, if they're using different videoclips from different performances, they're not using the audio belonging to each of those clips?

And if a music show simply uses a different, clean audio track not coming from the performances - because it takes less time and effort and it's easier and it sounds so much better to them - then it doesn't matter at all whether a group has sung live, with or without backtrack, at their performances since the audio came from another source anyway?

I can’t find it now but there used to be a musician who explained why MR videos not proof of they singing abilities. For me, I don’t take them that seriously. I like watching MR videos because I can hear they voices, whether it’s live or not it doesn’t matter. It’s fun but that’s about it.

Mr removed can't beat the Queens

i hate the LAR (pre-recorded) vocals the most because it gives kpop fans false expectations. they start to believe it's possible for idols to sound stable while dancing, and when they hear a genuinely live vocals where the idols sound out of breath, they think that the idols are bad singers cause they're so used to the perfect fake vocals

MR Removed videos used to be a thing back in the days, now only handful talks about it

The best Mr Removed you'll never hear

You still care about mr videos? Those have been proven to be a shitty way of determinating singing ability years and years ago

they are pointless for pre-recorded stages especially