Who’s gonna have a national hit first? TXT or Treasure?

Quote from babymon-gals

Well decide.

no i don't want to - you can't make me

I don't know much about TXT other than i really like Run Away so I'll say Treasure for now

none

Quote from selfmate

no i don't want to - you can't make me

I don't know much about TXT other than i really like Run Away so I'll say Treasure for now

You should check out Ghosting! It's really good.

quote me when any one of them gets a national hit (that is if we haven't gone through another reform)

as someone said before, none

Quote from dryheat

You should check out Ghosting! It's really good.

External Content open.spotify.com

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

External Content youtu.be

Content embedded from external sources will not be displayed without your consent.

Display all external content

Through the activation of external content, you agree that personal data may be transferred to third party platforms. We have provided more information on this in our privacy policy.

i gave the entire album a listen when it came out and again just now but didn't click for me sorry...keep recommending stuff to though i'm always open enough to give new things a try

Quote from babymon-gals

TXT has some really good songs. I’d suggest Blue Orangade

i gave it a listen and its not my style sorry. Again as per dryheat above if you have other recommendations keep throwing them at me i'm more than happy to give them a shot

Quote from babymon-gals

TXT has some really good songs. I’d suggest Blue Orangade

Blue Orangeade is so cute

Love the MV too

I think both have a solid chance. Yeah gp isn't into kpop anymore but any song have a good chance to become a hit if it's korean's taste and catchy enough.

TXT - 75k

The Boyz - 50K

TXT or TBZ for now.

National hit seems like an impossible dream for boy groups right now lol. Like even a regular sized hit seems unattainable.

But I'll bet on txt. With the right song and promotion they can get a normal hit at the very least.

more like treasure vs enphren as they are number 2 behind treasure

What's the standard to be consider as national hit? Song like love scenario, growl or spring day?

Even if they wouldn't have national hit, TXT and Treasure already have a dedicated fandoms, so positively both will be successful in the future.

For now, TXT are doing okay.

https://mobile.twitter.com/TXTCHART_KR/status/1352426214762246144

GP doesn't seem interested in the new BG unfortunately... but if I had to bet on one of the two, I would say TXT.

gp is more interested in ggs lately but it isnt impossible for one of them to get a nh but well see.

I am not even thinking about a national hit right now, I just want Treasure to actually chart first. In a few years, I believe Treasure will definately get a national hit. Anyways, stream this bop:

As others have said, I don’t think either will have a national hit - just a minor hit would be a massive success for a 4th gen boy group. I would say TXT has the better odds as they have the best charting record and their music style seems more appealing to the GP.

If you just based on the fact that you need X amount of attempts (song) to get a national hit, most likely TXT. Then when you take into account their style of music they showed, I think TXT songs are much more gp friendly than Treasure. Based on that I would say TXT;

National hits can surprise you. But it's more likely to be txt

TXT has the best bet rn, but neither group actually has good digitals so anything is possible. Blue Hour deserved but Korea is sadly tasteless.

Screenshot_20210124_211856_com.spotify.music.jpgIf TXT puts out a rock song or ballad, I bet they'd have a chance with the GP, but right now TXT just wants to experience different styles. Not for nothing do Korean discography, covers and Japanese songs differ from each other, you may notice that TXT confuses people when you find their music in unexpected places.

Let fate decide, this entire thread is a circlejerk.

Treasure is still a 5 month old group. They're trying different styles. More likely it will be Txt. But I will be surprised if Treasure will have one sooner.

No chance on this new chart but Treasure.

txt

blue hour actually managed to enter melon

Hopefully my babies TXT, they deserve the world

Let me bookmark this thread and revive it when one of the groups get even a semi-national hit, hopefully during one of txt's upcomming cbs

Definitely TXT

Quote from selfmate

i gave the entire album a listen when it came out and again just now but didn't click for me sorry...keep recommending stuff to though i'm always open enough to give new things a try

Try wishlist

Quote from Afriyieau1

Try wishlist

i liked it more than the other two recommended ones previously but it still didn't get me initially like run away did so i will relisten to it later and see if it goes up or down but right now its a maybe

thank you for the recommedation

i dont see any of them doing it. but if one of them, txt

None of the above...

And treasure is another flop bg that won't make it from yg

what's the criteria for a national hit?

top 5 melon?

10 weeks on top 10 gaon?

it's based on chance or fate. lol.

but, treasure had a comeback and did not have national hit. if txt has a comeback soon and have a good song, they might have a hit. so, TXT.