1. Blackpink
2. Oh my girl
3. Mamamoo
4. Red Velvet
5. Twice
Brave Girls: too soon to tell, but as many other viral groups in the past, they don't last long at the top
Opinions?
1. Blackpink
2. Oh my girl
3. Mamamoo
4. Red Velvet
5. Twice
Brave Girls: too soon to tell, but as many other viral groups in the past, they don't last long at the top
Opinions?
You’re underestimating Twice. And it’s too early to place Oh My Girl that high.
You’re underestimating Twice. And it’s too early to place Oh My Girl that high.
Psycho > Hip > Feel Special
Dingga > ICSM
?
More & More>Dingga and Physco wasn’t exactly the average RV release
BLACKPINK > Oh My Girl > MAMAMOO > TWICE >ITZY
Red Velvet need a comeback post-reform and it's too early to say anything for Brave Girls.
More & More>Dingga and Physco wasn’t exactly the average RV release
More & More wasn't bigger than Dingga.
Dingga is #86 on Gaon in it's 28th week while More & More was #193 in it's 28th week.... There is a clear discrepancy and Dingga will probably be surpassing or coming very close to it's points soon.
OT:
BLACKPINK > Oh My Girl > MAMAMOO > TWICE >ITZY
Red Velvet need a comeback post-reform and it's too early to say anything for Brave Girls.
I think we should wait considering a few of these groups are having new comebacks soon. But as it stands I still think twice should be considered at least on par with omg since they are close with bp in overall digital points due to past hits. After that I think it's red velvet, mamamoo a bit behind and then itzy. But this ranking can be easily interchangeable
Honestly outside of BP, sometimes Mamamoo and possibly RV (we have to see if their next CB is a hit our not) the rest aren't really that great digitally. Ggs aren't able to chart high and keep their positions for ages anymore.
Brave girls currently is the biggest of the lot but is an anomaly because their sing went mega viral but we need to seen how they fare over a few more CBs to see if either their hype has either worn off or they're an established bona fide popular group
M&M is ranked at #64 on Gaon’s year chart with a digital index of 323 millions and Dingga is ranked at #156 with 159 million points.
I'll just stop arguing cause I don't want this to go back and forth. Sorry for derailing, OP.
Because m&m was released in 1st week of june 2020 vs dingaa's end of October 2020 release. If m&m was released around oct same type of charting would happen. It gets divided between two years.
What do you mean by digitally ? Selling Digitally or most streamed ?
I believe the title track peaked around the #50 mark but their pre-release single which came out 2 weeks before the title peaked at #7.
Mamamoo ?
Didn't Psycho outcharted Hip, When all the moomoos wasted the entire month to tell to reveluv how Hip was much bigger than Psycho -_-
Sure, that happened almost two years ago. After that, Monster was a big flop
Sure, that happened almost two years ago. After that, Monster was a big flop
so you're comparing a sub unit to a group promo -_________________-
any other intelligent comparison like this ??
so you're comparing a sub unit to a group promo -_________________-
any other intelligent comparison like this ??
Put Hwasa and whatever other member in a sub unit and they’ll for sure do better than Monster
Woohoo
Display More1. Blackpink
2. Oh my girl
3. Mamamoo
4. Red Velvet
5. Twice
Brave Girls: too soon to tell, but as many other viral groups in the past, they don't last long at the top
Opinions?
Nah it's :
BP
OMG
BG
RV
Mamamoo
2020-2021 edition ^
I'll just stop arguing cause I don't want this to go back and forth. Sorry for derailing, OP.
(sorry if you didn’t wanna be quoted)
Because m&m was released in 1st week of june 2020 vs dingaa's end of October 2020 release. If m&m was released around oct same type of charting would happen. It gets divided between two years.
Fair but Dingga has still not crossed that 300 million mark (is at 275 million if I remember correctly) and it’s been over half a year now so it’s comparable to More&More’s end of the year numbers.
You must hate Twice to place them at the bottom
You must hate Twice to place them at the bottom
OP has a known Twice hate boner
Korea
1) Blackpink
2) Brave Girls
3)Mamamoo (i've taken Hwasa into consideration, else bump mamamoo down to #5)
4) OMG (still need to see whether D3 manage to get into top10)
5)GIDLE (they went top10 at least, but scandal killed their momentum) or ITZY (could be #4, if MITM goes top10)
Global
1) Blackpink
2) Twice
3) ITZY
4) Red Velvet
5) GIDLE
(sorry if you didn’t wanna be quoted)
Fair but Dingga has still not crossed that 300 million mark (is at 275 million if I remember correctly) and it’s been over half a year now so it’s comparable to More&More’s end of the year numbers.
The points r reduced. Charting changed alot when the new melon reform was introduced.
And considering dingaa is charting much higher than m&m on gaon in its 28th week it'll pass 300M soon enough. M&m already out of gaon200 by week 28. Overall both r similar mediocre performing songs. ICSM is similar too.
You must hate Twice to place them at the bottom
But that's how they performed last year if we are taking the most recent performance
Hopefully twice can overturn this with Taste of Love
I think we should wait considering a few of these groups are having new comebacks soon. But as it stands I still think twice should be considered at least on par with omg since they are close with bp in overall digital points due to past hits. After that I think it's red velvet, mamamoo a bit behind and then itzy. But this ranking can be easily interchangeable
I think at this juncture, should exclude red velvet for the time being. Very hard to judge them based on a 2-year old song.
Why no twice?
Cause their latest charting in korea is quite luckluster?
Mamomoo - at least their prerelease reached #7
ITZY is outcharting them soon now at #13 (but longevity another question)
OMG had two monster hits and D3 seems like another moderate one for them
Aside from BP and BG, only Gidle made it to top10 on Melon
Cause their latest charting in korea is quite luckluster?
Mamomoo - at least their prerelease reached #7
ITZY is outcharting them soon now at #13 (but longevity another question)
OMG had two monster hits and D3 seems like another moderate one for them
Aside from BP and BG, only Gidle made it to top10 on Melon
Just wanted to note that mamamoo reached 7 on melon with dingga last year
Mentioned already in 2nd line
Mentioned already in 2nd line
yeah somehow i missed that lol it’s just that your last sentence contradicted with it so my mind just kinda glossed over it
The disrespect towards twice and Mamamoo in this thread.
Their discography and their charting is too good for this bs.
The disrespect towards twice and Mamamoo in this thread.
Their discography and their charting is too good for this bs.
The thread title - "now"
No disrespecting but bringing in past performance is irrelevant. Globally, twice is still top5 as their spotify streams numbers are second to BP only
Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!