Which is more better in terms of the group concept, public image and artistry or musicianship among these three SM girl groups? Girls' Generation, F(X) or Red Velvet)

SNSD overall.

Concept - Red Velvet

Public Image - SNSD

Artistry - all 3

Muscianship - SNSD for discography

SNSD. Too bad f(x) career felt like just a short one

少女时代

SNSD for sure.

But f(x) was really underrated. Too bad that SM did them so dirty.

Quote from crystalblues

Concept - Red Velvet

Public Image - SNSD

Artistry - all 3 (f(x) and RV tend to be more experimental though).

Musicianship - SNSD as the members have written many of the groups songs and their own solos, as well as Taeyeon and Hyo producing for themselves and other artists. (I would love for SM to let RV start writing and producing).

OMG TWINS I LEGIT WAS THINKING THE SAME THINGGGGGGGGGG

SNSD has all of them so SNSD

Neither fx nor red velvet can touch Snsd in terms of public image. They are on another leauge.

Same with concepts snsd have done a lot of them.

images (99).jpeg

But I'll vote for Fx. Their discography is S tier.

Concept: SNSD. They are one of the rare groups that attempt and pull off any idea they are given

Public image: SNSD. I mean come on culture icons says it all

Artist/musicianship: SNSD. Almost all members have some sort of career as solo musicians and most members have contributed to the creation of their music from writing lyrics, coming up with concepts/ideas and producing.