Better song : Spaghetti vs Gnarly

Spaghetti is easy listening (if we ignore the weird ass MV).

Gnarly is more iconic though.

Spaghetti does not deserve the honor of being compared to Gnarly imo. I would say Gnarly is objectively worse but subjectively better for me, if that makes any sense.

Gnarly is miles better than Spaghetti

I like both, what do I do now

Ended up voting for gnarly i agree with keyboardwarrior7 that it's iconic

Btw i watched both videos and saw my initial reaction

IMG_20251024_192620.jpg

And a comment made 3 months later said it was a cultural reset gnarly really aged well!

Gnarly is just too iconic and weird in a good way. It took a risk and succeeded. Spaghetti is weird too but still played it "safe" for what it is, imo.

Gnarly is a tragic song it was saved by the performance

Spaghetti easily! The only thing Gnarly has over Spaghetti is more time for people to get used to it

Gnarly was impactful but mostly thanks to the girls' performance. I still wouldn't put it in my playlist. Spaghetti is more palatable, still flawed but catchy enough. The girls also help selling the song.

gnarly is a crime against music and it deserves a razzia

spaguetti just the flop bin

either way, it always extremely strange that people who are fans of that bulding and this 'songs' are often out there to call any song not released by their bias TRASH, FLOP, MESS

specially when it's released by succesful rival groups

but when ACTUALL mess is released by they faves they forcefeed themselves into loving it, hiding behind 'performances', 'i listented to it 29493857859834 time and now i LOVE it'

Quote from Tatiana1820

gnarly is a crime against music and it deserves a razzia

spaguetti just the flop bin

either way, it always extremely strange that people who are fans of that bulding and this 'songs' are often out there to call any song not released by their bias TRASH, FLOP, MESS

specially when it's released by succesful rival groups

but when ACTUALL mess is released by they faves they forcefeed themselves into loving it, hiding behind 'performances', 'i listented to it 29493857859834 time and now i LOVE it'

Display More

I'm not sure what you're talking about, but you seem angry

Spaghetti is less annoying

Quote from SooYoung

I used to like you until i see this 😲😲😲😲

then stop liking me please at least my ears like me

can't believe anyone would 'unlike' me because of gnarly

i can't listen to gnarly but still spaguetti is not it

Quote from Fansamy

I'm not sure what you're talking about, but you seem angry

i have the right to tho

lately everytime a new kpop song drops, specially from big ggs, a huge part 'that' building worshipers can't stop screeming at the top of their lungs how that song is TRASH, MESS, the worst song ever released , trying to bum rival group's combacks with their negativity all across social networks day and night , specially against fine songs such as dirty work and pit stop, but when actuall MESS drop, there's only crickets ...

yes i have the right to sound a tiny bit angry .