[instiz] Karina who said she lost weight because "she didn't had weight of an Idol"

reminds of JYP telling Jihyo she needed some "weight management"

Quote from bartkun

that was rude as hell back then

and it's different when you make decision yourself, and when you're forced to do so

also I remember if I'm correct it was in Lee Youngji's show that Karina said she eat what she wants but then when she needs to lose weight she wears more clothing layers and just goes out and run for few hours

I think she only does that because of "pressure" either direct or indirect

sure what JYP did was direct pressure but I'm pretty sure merely being an idol is sufficient indirect pressure

Quote from SooYoung

Just being an idol puts pressure to lose weight

And having so many eyes on you doesn't help either

But considering that you use JYP and Jihyo situation

I would say i much prefer aespa pressure have

In the sense that the direct pressure that JYP put on jihyo push her to lose weight in a very short amount of time and a lot of weight which leads to unhealthy diet and idol gaining back their weight during break to go back to unhealthy diet before comeback era

It's still pressure but after seeing so many times aespa girlies showing their meal and how they eat

I prefer how they handle it

They don't have a pressure direct so they eat everything they want and then work out by going to the gym or pilate to maintain a healthy diet

Which is better and avoid the yo-yo effect of unhealthy diet

Display More

the question is we don't know if they have direct pressure currently (I'm pretty sure they had it in the past even if we don't know directly they had it)

in the sense that we only know because JYP telling Jihyo on camera...

I'm pretty sure prior to debut or just after debut all the members were told (most likely) in private some things about "weight management" - obviously I cannot confirm for sure since I've never heard of the members talking about it but it's a educated guess since it's a message that most of us kpop fans are aware of...

now whether that still happens NOW given the levels of success Aespa and Karina in particular have - probably not

So unnecessary, she always looks great

good to stop eating when you feel full

Quote from SooYoung

Actually i remember reading a book about the secret of the oldest village in japan and one pf their secret was to eat until they are 80% fullwonder

wonder how they estimate that. seems hard. they really are good at math

Quote from selfmate

reminds of JYP telling Jihyo she needed some "weight management"

And he is right.

Weight Management is developing healthy eating habits, regular exercise and a stable mental health, it's not a system to target a weight goal rather it's used to regulate where you need to be for a career in physical performance.

This could be a Marathon, Triathlon, Swimming or a Korean Idol where you need to be stable when Singing while Dancing.

TWICE has recorded 257 songs and has choreo for at least 100, JiHyo of the Survival Show Sixteen wouldn't had made it if she stayed the same.

JYPark's Weight Management borders on extreme for an Entertainer.

Quote from jimeous

And he is right.

Weight Management is developing healthy eating habits, regular exercise and a stable mental health, it's not a system to target a weight goal rather it's used to regulate where you need to be for a career in physical performance.

This could be a Marathon, Triathlon, Swimming or a Korean Idol where you need to be stable when Singing while Dancing.

TWICE has recorded 257 songs and has choreo for at least 100, JiHyo of the Survival Show Sixteen wouldn't had made it if she stayed the same.

JYPark's Weight Management borders on extreme for an Entertainer.

Display More

I agree with the part in bold but the rest maybe not so much

jihyo who had been in jyp since 8 and during sixteen she was 16 aka prime teenage years - JYP could have said it in private - hell I'm sure he did considering she was 18 when she debuted in twice but to call her out publicly like that

jihyo was also very conscious of her body and image during that time I personally think it was uncalled for

Quote from selfmate

I agree with the part in bold but the rest maybe not so much

jihyo who had been in jyp since 8 and during sixteen she was 16 aka prime teenage years - JYP could have said it in private - hell I'm sure he did considering she was 18 when she debuted in twice but to call her out publicly like that

jihyo was also very conscious of her body and image during that time I personally think it was uncalled for

Jihyo was with JYPE for a decade so would have been told about her condition by JYPE Trainers over the years and probably ignored it.

Being shamed publicly isn't bad if there is foundation of the criticism and JiHyo's response with "All about the Bass" was the best reply, so good, it almost seemed scripted.

Anyway, this is about Karina...