how is exo worth more than bts when they made lesser impact in the music industry

I’m their sugar mommy

Do they have any source

no one believed that

No one knows what BTS are worth tbh and SCMP is not known for journalistic integrity.

They did make a lot of money prior to enlistment. Not more money than BTS/BP but definitely more money than rest of kpop that’s for sure. Certainly more than anyone at SM/JYP/YG. I don’t think NCT/17/twice etc made more than EXO up to 2018/19. Bigger tours. Bigger album sales. Endorsements. Both group and solo. They had it all.

Yeah I wouldn't take stuff like this seriously.

I remember for a long period people really thought that the members were only worth 8 million dollars each..including me

Quote from invstor099

They generated est 3.9bil in economic value is its weird to see such a number

https://www.cnbc.com/video/202…ill-cost-south-korea.html

SCMP is an unreliable publication, absolutely no one knows how wealthy BTS are.

Not them setting up Exo like that. From 2012 till now, they have never even generated $1B in revenue for SME. At least we can debate TVXQ bringing that amount from their Jpn touring.

Quote from invstor099

They generated est 3.9bil in economic value is its weird to see such a number

https://www.cnbc.com/video/202…ill-cost-south-korea.html

As of 2021, it was $5.1B. But we will never know the exact wealth of BTS members but deducing that they make the most money EVER as a group from SK, anyone putting them anywhere but #1 is either biased or delusional. Even the FREE Yet To Come in Cinemas that every ARMY already viewed for FREE TWICE still generated $40M and they added dates until the end of 02/12/23.

Quote from invstor099

But I wonder if the fact there’s chinese members has a play in it since its a chinese company.

SCMP used to be respected though, before it got bought over by alibaba

Quote from invstor099

How big was tvxq?

$40m and $120-150m doesn’t make sense unless bang pd takes 1/3 of the revenue like lsm does

I remember reading articles around 2012 that TVXQ as five and as two already brought in over $1B from Japanese album sales and touring but it's been a hot minute and I'm too lazy to look it up for you lol

Quote from invstor099

The bp numbers are sus too. I bet Lisa earns a lot plus she did variety appearances and trended in china

The article's worth as much as the next random trust me source Twitter post

idk why even low-brow publications like that write articles that anyone with common sense can tell are wrong lol

EXO are definitely up there with the richest idols, no doubt, but BTS are 100% on top, and probably with a pretty sizeable gap. I feel like people don't realise just how much money their tours and merch sales etc made in the last few years. Their advertising fee was the highest in the industry, their album sales index alone doubles that of any other group.

Quote from invstor099

This? https://www.allkpop.com/articl…-usd-is-bigger-than-big-3

Thanks for digging it up lol I stopped paying attention to TVXQ/most SM acts after 2015 so I was not aware they made $2B in 2018. This is just proving this list even more inaccurate. They should be at #2.

What a bunch of crap. It sounds like a troll article lmaooo

For anyone's wondering- this is how much money BTS brings in HYBE...

Thread

BTS is a whole brand far beyond SM, JYP & YG

Another thread made me inspired to make this, but in terms of revenue and profitability this is true. BTS actually outgrossed SM, JYP & YG in yearly revenue. It's beyond my imagination what a feat this is.

In their 2020 yearly report they generated;

SM - 579 billion won
JYP - 144 billion won
YG - 255 billion won

BTS (group) - 674 billion won

Everyone was struggling with pandemic and no live concerts and BTS still proved us wrong.

forum.allkpop.com/suite/attachment/260904/

Two years after, BTS is still…

sweetenerstan

Jan 6th 2023

Just in 2022 alone, according to HYBE, BTS is expected to contribute 60-65% of their whole earnings which is like 1,025 trillion won - 1,105 triilion won. That's more than SM's whole earnings and more than YG + JYP's revenue combined. In one whole year alone, with no world tour and only 1 compilation album.

BTS is far above these groups esp in earnings. One whole year or 2 years of BTS could be a decade earnings of Bigbang or TVXQ. Not even EXO.

Once you reached their level of success & popularity internationally and constantly printing big money, it's not shocking to earn that much in short time only. Think of it, BTS have sold the most albums with an estimated album units of 130M. Whilst, they did not have the luck to tour as much as Bigbang or TVXQ in they prime years due to covid and military, they still made so much from other revenue streams like merch, content, IP, high paying brand endorsements and etc.

It actually is kinda amazing that they didn't have to go on grueling sched of touring just to make a lot of money. This year alone, they are estimated to bring in atleast 500B won with hiatus and most of their earnings are only coming from indirect revenue streams and back catalogs. That's how powerful they are.

People bringing up bigbang and TVXQ

Apart from album sales and touring which EXO did really well, they Completely ignore how valuable EXO members are individually. Sure not all EXO members do equally as well but Baekhyun himself sells as much as a WHOLE group. And we have Kai with his global endorsements. And then D.O with MULTIPLE hit dramas and movies. Not mention how much merch Chanyeol Sehun Baekhyun sell from bubble to individual item sales. Since I’m not following Bigbang closely enough I won’t mention them so I’m not sure if they have multiple ppl this valuable as well. But TVXQ is certainly are not more valuable than EXO. Physically, digitally, and individual member wise EXO are without a doubt bigger.

I guess “other avenues” exists for everyone else but will be ignored when it comes to EXO.

god damn I knew that SCMP wasn't any good stuff

but damn Jack Ma's asspiece mighta actually catfished some unlucky views.

All I can think of is that BTS only blew up internationaly after 2017 and that the members, especialy Suga complained on how poor the agency was before that (There exist a interview where the boys showed the food they got when they were rookies vs. what they buy since making a lot money) and EXO allready blew up as they had debuted in 2012

These rankings never make sense and are mostly always just made up numbers from the start, they then get published, and a year later 3-4 other sites will post their networth rankings based on the previous random rankings, thus making it less and less reliable for every year passing

This list in particular looks like someone just googled random comments about networth and went with it

Well people used to say BB had sold 150M singles worldwide.

Quote from ISaidISaid

People bringing up bigbang and TVXQ

Apart from album sales and touring which EXO did really well, they Completely ignore how valuable EXO members are individually. Sure not all EXO members do equally as well but Baekhyun himself sells as much as a WHOLE group. And we have Kai with his global endorsements. And then D.O with MULTIPLE hit dramas and movies. Not mention how much merch Chanyeol Sehun Baekhyun sell from bubble to individual item sales. Since I’m not following Bigbang closely enough I won’t mention them so I’m not sure if they have multiple ppl this valuable as well. But TVXQ is certainly are not more valuable than EXO. Physically, digitally, and individual member wise EXO are without a doubt bigger.

I guess “other avenues” exists for everyone else but will be ignored when it comes to EXO.

Display More

I know hes not in TVXQ anymore but it's not a stretch to say TVXQ is worth more than EXO.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.therichest.com/rich-powerful/heres-how-kim-jaejoong-became-the-richest-k-pop-star-in-the-world/amp/

Quote from Drew_B

I know hes not in TVXQ anymore but it's not a stretch to say TVXQ is worth more than EXO.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/w…op-star-in-the-world/amp/

the claims of Jaejoongs wealth have never made any sense whatsoever, and the only source of it is some random article over years ago that has been recycled since. His networth somehow always stayed the same (100m) since as well

Superior discography

Quote from invstor099

Can someone explain this to me? Im not sure if this is a biased article

https://www.scmp.com/magazines…et-worths-ranked-bts-puma

It doesnt makes sense how they are worth 1bil and bts 120-150mil when bts made more impact on the k-pop industry. Is it just brand endorsements? In terms of album sales isnt bts > exo?

It’s a real qns lol

Display More

The true richest idols on that list are TVXQ, they've been making millions for almost 20 years now. They've been able to sell 1 million concert tickets in a single Japanese tour alone and they are only two.

Those are the richest.

no hate but highly doubt that considering :

A ) how much BP has gotten over born pink concert tix

B ) BTS 's concerts & cinema events in 2022 + the money they helped make for YTC in Busan

Quote from sassily

idk why even low-brow publications like that write articles that anyone with common sense can tell are wrong lol

EXO are definitely up there with the richest idols, no doubt, but BTS are 100% on top, and probably with a pretty sizeable gap. I feel like people don't realise just how much money their tours and merch sales etc made in the last few years. Their advertising fee was the highest in the industry, their album sales index alone doubles that of any other group.

also like its crazy the amount BTS make in many of the countries etc... for example Japan.

BTS has been the highest earning artist in Japan in GENERAL ie above Japanese artists as well... for the past 2 years (2021 and 2022)

earning over 160M in 2021 and around 94M in 2022 (with just a compilation album). Again keep in mind this is without touring and from ONE COUNTRY ALONE. You can imagine how much they earn from all the other things in their career etc.

Quote from ISaidISaid

But TVXQ is certainly are not more valuable than EXO.

Lol. TVXQ is far richer than EXO as a group and more valuable. When it comes to rankings, it's definitely BTS<TVXQ<Bigbang

Exo might be 4th in the ranking, but I'm sure BP will easily catch up to them now that they are active and have a bigger brand overall.

LOL~~~!!!!!!!

that article HAD to had been written by an Exo-L.

genuinely hilarious