Girl’s beheading in India spurs calls for ‘honour killings’ law

  • Source: Al Jazeera


    Police in northern India say they have arrested a man who beheaded his daughter and carried her severed head to the village police station, a case that spurred calls for a new law against the so-called “honour killings”.


    The man told police he had attacked his 17-year-old daughter with an axe on Wednesday in anger over her relationship with a man.


    “He said he saw his daughter in a compromising position with a man and he beheaded her in a fit of rage,” Anurag Vats, the police superintendent of Hardoi district in northern Uttar Pradesh state, told the Thomson Reuters Foundation on Thursday.


    “He has confessed to his crime,” he said.


    Images of the man carrying the girl’s head were shared widely on social media, reigniting demands from women’s campaigners for a specific law against honour killings to help protect potential victims and improve police investigations.


    Human rights groups say thousands of women and girls are killed across South Asia and the Middle East each year by family members angered at perceived damage to their “honour”.


    Perceived offences can include eloping, fraternising with men or any transgression of conservative values regarding women.


    Last month, a woman was burned alive by family members over an interfaith relationship in Uttar Pradesh, local media reported, quoting police officials.


    “Daughters in India are seen as a sign of family honour, which results in such crimes,” said Madhu Garg, the vice president of All India Democratic Women Association’s Uttar Pradesh chapter.


    “The issue of the right to choice needs immediate attention and a separate law should be made for dealing with honour killing.”


    India recorded 24 honour killings in 2019. Two years earlier, Uttar Pradesh registered 14 of the country’s 92 such killings, the government’s crime data shows.


    Campaigners say government statistics on honour killing mask the scale of the crime, with women at greater risk than men.


    “Almost 70 percent of the victims in honour killings are women, and almost all of them are from the upper caste,” said Arockiya Samy Kathir, the founder of non-profit Evidence, which has for years worked on honour killings in south India.


    The Indian government in 2018 asked all states to set up special cells comprising police and welfare officers and a 24-hour helpline to help couples facing harassment or those seeking protection but campaigners say compliance has been poor.

  • yo india needs to chill

    yall makin us look bad bro

    how am i supposed to be a confident indian when my home country b pullin this bs.

    thank god i was born in america

  • Why wasn't there a law against this in place before that even took place?? Men who think they own their daughter's sexuality are less than trash. I hope he rots in hell for what he did to her.

    there are laws against this .. but they are still some secluded places.. mostly in some places like Uttar Pradesh and Haryana such cases can pop up once in a while



    Many people dont understand the consequences of their actions...


    Its sad that these things still happen sometimes but the truth is a few Indians are still super conservative and would rather defend their honour than their own children

  • I will be surprised that in the 21st century there are still countries with such tough patriarchy that simply reaches the point of absurdity. I will never understand how you can "accidentally" kill your own daughter out of anger. But what about blood ties, humanity, in the end, the human right to life, protection of the state, where is it all? This is terrible, I am very sorry for the poor girl. This man deserves to die in torment

    these are generally very backwards, overly conservative and traditional communities in more rural areas that are stuck in their way of living and thinking and have never changed over the past 100 years. in India, many people, both educated and not, think highly of what others think of them. "what will society think" is such a common way of thinking, even in the cities. for instance, if a normal university-aged girl is in a relationship she will often have to hide it from her parents because if they knew they might even force her to break it off. most wouldn't attack her but would yell at her and say its a distraction and yada yada yada. not all parents, but a good number. it's of course even crazier in smaller towns and rural areas. they take it to a whole other level by considering the daughter's worth to be as much as her singlehood and "purity". they consider relationships to be "cheap" and "embarrasing" and that they're tainting their family's honor by being a young, unmarried girl seen with a guy. its absolutely crazy and horrifying.

  • Why wasn't there a law against this in place before that even took place?? Men who think they own their daughter's sexuality are less than trash. I hope he rots in hell for what he did to her.

    Laws can only go so far about changing culture. Honor killings have been going on for a long time. There have been ancient remains found of dead children. Even today there’s remote tribes living as if they were in the Stone Age while there’s people in outer space. This obviously all has to do with culture

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!